President Barack Obama’s draft of new rules for funding embryonic stem cell research will interfere with important work in finding disease treatments, says Consumer Watchdog, a Santa Monica-based consumer advocate group.
The group has often been critical of California’s $3 billion stem cell research program. But in its Wednesday statement, Consumer Watchdog endorsed changes proposed by the program, the California Institute for Regenerative Medicine, or CIRM, along with the Interstate Alliance on Stem Cell Research.
The problem, according to Consumer Watchdog, is that Obama’s new rules conflict with funding guidelines President Bush enacted on Aug. 9, 2001. So about 20 lines of embryonic stem cells developed under the Bush guidelines cannot be funded under the Obama guidelines, proposed under Obama’s March 9, 2009, executive order.
One issue is Obama’s requirement that federally funded stem cell lines be derived from embryos whose donors were informed in detail about the commercial potential of this research, and that they would not get any monetary benefit. But some of the Bush-approved lines came from donors who were given less detailed information that omitted the commercial potential.
It makes sense to adopt the new guidelines from now on, but is unfair to impose them retroactively, said John M. Simpson, Consumer Watchdog’s stem cell project director.
The draft regulations are available by clicking here.
Comments to the draft regulations can be made online by clicking here.
CIRM’s comments are here. (in PDF).
The Interstate Alliance’s comments are here. (also in PDF).