Judge rules UC system bias suit can proceed
By: JENNIFER KABBANY - Staff Writer | ∞
MURRIETA ---- A lawsuit claiming the UC system discriminates against Christian beliefs by rejecting some private Christian schools' courses for college-entrance credit may proceed, a federal judge ruled Tuesday, rejecting the university's argument that the case should be tossed.
U.S. District Judge S. James Otero's ruling states that claims in the lawsuit are worth pursuing. The suit was filed by Calvary Chapel Christian School in Murrieta, six of its students and the Association of Christian Schools International, which represents more than 4,000 religious schools nationwide.
"Members of the Supreme Court have articulated on various occasions that a university's decisions regarding admissions policies deserve a measure of sanctity," Otero stated. "However ... the freedom that a university enjoys to determine its own admissions policies is not without limit."
On Tuesday, the Murrieta students' attorney hailed the ruling as a crucial victory validating the lawsuit, while a spokesman for the University of California system dismissed the decision as "no surprise" and said the 10-campus university system should prevail in the final verdict.
The lawsuit contends the system discriminates against Christian schools by rejecting some courses for college-entrance credit because they include or are based upon Christian viewpoints, citing several English, science and elective courses rejected by the system in the last few years.
Part of those claims include that the UC system is denying some science courses that use popular Christian science textbooks because its officials don't approve of the fact that they espouse creationism, or the belief that a supreme being created the universe.
UC system officials have maintained that there is no such bias against Christian academics and that they just want students admitted into the system to be prepared for its academic rigors.
"We will vigorously defend ourselves," Ricardo Vasquez, a spokesman for the UC system, said in response to the ruling. "We believe we have not been discriminating and we believe that ultimately we'll prevail because the facts are on our side."
Murrieta attorney Robert Tyler, who is representing Calvary Chapel Christian School and its six students, hailed the ruling as a "great initial victory."
"The facts of the case as presented so far reveal the UC school system has engaged in discriminating against Christian schools based on their viewpoints and not based on objective standards," Tyler said, adding that he expects the case to go to trial in six months to a year.
None of the six students named in the lawsuit was available for comment Tuesday, Tyler said.
He said that of those six students, two graduated in June, one of whom went to a private Christian university and another who went to a junior college to take part in their basketball program. The remaining four are applying to the UC system, he said.
The UC system's Vasquez said that nine seniors from Calvary Chapel Christian School in Murrieta were enrolled in UC universities and start classes this fall. He said their enrollment illustrates that the school's students have access to the system, which its officials say is the largest public research university system in the world.
The crux of the lawsuit centers around several rejected courses submitted by Calvary Chapel for credit into the UC system, such as "Christianity's Influence on America," which a UC document cited as "too narrow (and) too specialized" as reasons for not approving the course.
Another Calvary Chapel course rejected by the UC system was "Christianity and Morality in American Literature." The class was described in documents as an "intensive study in textual criticism aimed at elevating the ability of students to engage literary works." Authors students would have studied included Mark Twain, Edgar Allen Poe, Benjamin Franklin and C.S. Lewis.
Otero summarized the lawsuit by stating that it argues the UC system is violating the school's and students' First Amendment rights through "content regulation, viewpoint discrimination, prescription of orthodoxy and chilling of rights."
"Fundamentally, the government is forbidden from engaging in regulation of speech based on its substantive content or its message," he stated.
Contact staff writer Jennifer Kabbany at (951) 676-4315, Ext. 2625, or jkabbany@californian.com. To comment on this article, go to www.californian.com.
More Stories
Advertisement
liberal wrote on Aug 9, 2006 7:48 AM:The Liberal agenda remove religion from society then nothing will be in the way of government to control and take over our lives. God is getting in the way of government domination.
Steve wrote on Aug 9, 2006 8:37 AM:HA, that's funny "liberal" because it's the conservative right-wing that's a puppet of the fundies that's controlling the government. I went to Golden West community college and not all of the courses I took would transfer over to the universities either and I don't think I was discriminated against. Once again, it's the so called christians tying up the courts and crying foul.
To Steve: wrote on Aug 9, 2006 10:54 AM:If you took the time to find out what is not being accepted you would understand, there is a foul and should be dealt with. Most of the books being rejected are the same books other schools are using with scripture at the beginning of each chapter. And besides, if the schools can teach evolution, then we should be able to teach creationism. Some courses do not transfer but when ligitimate classes that should be able to be transferred and not allowed, that is discrimination...learn your facts...
CR wrote on Aug 9, 2006 12:17 PM:Of course the UC system is biased--they want only brain-washed products to graduate. No real thinking for yourself is allowed--you must mimic the thinking of the liberal professors, or you will flunk the class. Unfortunately it will take much more than this lawsuit to change the system.
UC System is Racist Too wrote on Aug 9, 2006 1:40 PM:Just look at the discriminatory manner in which students are admitted into the UCs. White students have to reach much higher standards than minority students for entrance. Is it any wonder the UC discriminates against Christians? No.
Equality Now wrote on Aug 9, 2006 2:47 PM:UC should stop being so biased towards rational thought. Our schools should give equal time to the theory that 1+1=2 as they do to the theories 1+1=3 and 1+1=ganesh.
Rid wrote on Aug 9, 2006 7:15 PM:You have to get rid of these liberal professors. It is their way of thinking or nothing. They will be the death of our children.
First name only. Comments including last names, contact addresses, e-mail addresses or phone numbers will be deleted. Attempts to misrepresent your identity or impersonate any person will not be approved. All comments are screened before they appear online, so please keep them brief. Comments reflect the views of those commenting and not necessarily those of the North County Times or its staff writers. Click here to view additional comment policies.
Today's Stories
Advertisement