Grandparents raising grandchildren have help

By: ELEANOR ROBERTS - For the North County Times | Sunday, November 5, 2006 8:55 PM PST

Gilbert Villarreal and his wife Cynthia sit with their grandchildren, Arlene Ortiz, 4, right, and Sonya Ortiz, 2, while in their Vista home last month. The couple waits for the adoption of the young girls, who are the daughters of Gilbert Villarreal`s daughter, to be final.
Hayne Palmour IV
Order a copy of this photo
Visit our Photo Gallery

VISTA ---- Cynthia Villarreal knew when she married her husband that his two teenage daughters would be moving in with them.

What she didn't anticipate was the phone call they received from Child Protective Services asking them to take care of another child, the one from her husband's other teenage daughter who became pregnant at 15.

Their mother was unable to take care of them and Villarreal's grandchildren were being "shuffled around and left with whoever was willing to watch them," Villarreal said.

The process of gaining guardianship of their grandchildren meant being assigned an adoption social worker to handle the placement of the children and filling out paperwork; having to undergo background checks on their finances, home safety, and relationship; and having the parental rights of the biological parents terminated.

According to the 2005 American Community Survey, the Villarreals are just two of 17,000 grandparents who are responsible for raising their grandchildren in San Diego County, and that figure does not take into account the thousands of undeclared guardians raising grandchildren without full custody.

For grandparents like the Villarreals, the Kinship Care Program offers guidance about their rights, roles and support system. The program operates throughout San Diego County under the wing of YMCA Youth and Family Services and North County Lifeline.

Similar situations

Kinship Care coordinator Denise Turrubiate said the cornerstone of the support program is a weekly get-together for the guardians and children held at more than a dozen locations in the county. She said it's helpful for people who find themselves with the same questions and concerns to meet each other.

"This is a situation that defies everything, whether you are rich or poor, black or white, if you were raised Christian or Jewish," Turrubiate said. "Here, they come together and find themselves in the same situation."

Although some, like the Villarreals, have been asked by Child Protective Services to become guardians, Denise says that "90 percent of my workload is informal cases," meaning grandparents have answered a call to pick up the children or they have been baby-sitting and found the children have been abandoned. One of the participants, Pam Bordeaux, said, "Our daughter said she was going to go to a party for the night, but she didn't come back for a year. We didn't see her. There was no contact."

For many, these experiences are not openly discussed and Kinship participants are worried that they will be seen as failing the children if they ask for help.

But Bordeaux said that one of the things Kinship has taught her is that, "You are strong if you understand that you need help because you don't fully understand what is going on.

"When they first encounter the group, they may get embarrassed and be scared to tell their story. They may say, 'My kid was into drugs,' and are relieved when we raise our hands to show that this is what happened to us as well."

'You are a saint'

Although participants may feel embarrassed about their situation, many of the grandparents find praise from those close to them.

"People think you are a saint, but you just step in where you are needed," Bordeaux said.

Another grandparent, Peggy Maddocks, said, "I get it all the time, 'I don't know how you can do it.' But you just do; what else are you going to do?"

Bordeaux had 13 children and tells how her daughter "was picked up for numerous situations ---- drugs, forgery, you name it, she was trying to do it."

"When she was incarcerated the last time, she asked me if we would take the kids."

That was 11 years ago. Peggy now has full legal guardianship of her grandchildren, Willy and Ashley, and she has the right to keep their parents from seeing them. "The judge told us when we got guardianship that (their mother) is not to be in the house, she cannot be around the children alone," Bordeaux said.

Their mother has not contacted them for the past five years.

Parenting a second time

Parenting is difficult, and for a lot of the people in this group it was the last thing they thought they would be doing again. They didn't think they would have to pick up kids from school, buy them clothes of help with homework.

"They want to be grandparents and they don't get a chance to do that," Turrubiate said.

"The parents sometimes get to come in and go to the movies and we are the ones that are saying, 'You have to get your homework done, you have to get up in the morning,'" Bordeaux said. "So we have the parental roles and have lost the grandparent roles."

Grandparents aren't the only ones getting a lot of support from this group. So are the kids. Although they are brought to the group by their grandparents, a lot of them agreed the children are the ones who end up pestering their grandparents to not miss Kinship meetings. They get a chance to play with kids without having to explain their situation. Many of the kids have emotional and attachment problems due to their upbringing.

"Due to privacy laws," Turrubiate explains, "many grandparents cannot be part of family therapy that would help them understand how their grandkids are feeling."

One of the services recommended by Kinship is a program at Grossmont College that deals with these issues.

"We are doing a session now on how to care for the hurt child," Bordeaux said. Through Kinship and its programs, they learn to "raise these children to become very functioning adults."

Practical issues

Kinship is not only about emotional support, but also about the practicality of raising grandchildren. Guardians get help with finding funding, getting respite care, and receiving legal advice regarding custody and power of attorney.

Some grandparents are often classed as volunteer caregivers, depriving them of funds and other services given to foster parents.

"Sometimes they have the kids for years until they find out that they can get some form of funding," Turrubiate said of the options Kinship shows participants.

Housing situations many need to change, too. Aurora Corrizal was in senior housing when she took in three grandsons, Nicolas, 12, Ryan, 10, and Tyler, 8. She had to find a bigger house. Aurora was named "Grandparent of the Year" by Kinship North County in 2005.

On the Net:

http://www.fakce.org/

12 comment(s)[-]Go to Top

Skip wrote on Nov 6, 2006 7:56 AM:Just like in my neighborhood where you routinely see Pregnant Hispanic mothers pushing baby stollers, and being followed by their oldest children pushing more baby stollers. I still cannot figure out how they can afford to have so many kids. Just go to the local Home Town Buffet (Temecula) for dinner and you would swear you are in a different country, because none of the customers are speaking English.

Adam wrote on Nov 6, 2006 8:01 AM:This is predominately a Hispanic thing, because Hispanics have the highest birth rate among any ethnic group in the United States. Having kids at 15 years old is no big deal. That is the way it is in Mexico, and Mexico is moving here.

For the ultimate Anchor Baby Story wrote on Nov 6, 2006 8:06 AM:For the ultimate Anchor Baby Story, just GOOGLE this : 6 + 4 = 1 Tenuous Existence

All For It wrote on Nov 6, 2006 10:45 AM:This is a great program. It gives people who have already failed as a parent once a chance to screw up another generation. Way to go!

Don't blame Hispanics wrote on Nov 6, 2006 4:12 PM:My sister-in-law was Italian and had no motherly instincts! The Hispanic grandmother had to raise the child. They come in all colors.

Terry wrote on Nov 6, 2006 4:30 PM:Raising my three grandkids, 5,8 and 10, single, work two jobs, know how to do the babysitting shuffle. Happy they are all in school now, what's a grandma to do? Love them all.

From A Mexican wrote on Nov 7, 2006 1:10 PM:A 2004 study by the Washington, D.C.-based Population Resource Center found that there were 94.5 births per 1,000 Mexican girls between the ages of 15 and 19 in the United States, more than double the national average of 43 births per 1,000 women for the same age group. Latina magazine calls this an "epidemic." Mexicans call it the lottery. Illegal immigrant relatives can use the American-born kid as the first step on the path to citizenship; legalized Mexicans reap the benefits of government programs for poor parents and tax breaks. But before you join the Minutemen to stop this fleecing of American taxpayers, gabachos, consider: With your birthrates falling precipitously, every newborn Mexican ensures that you and your parents can leech off Social Security for a couple of years longer.

An American wrote on Nov 7, 2006 5:21 PM:Well I think it's GREAT that these grandparents are wiling to take in these kids. Can you imagine, your teenage daughter runs away or gets ... up by her mother/guardian and gets pregnant and then abandons the babies? What is a father to do? In these cases, step up and take care of his family, that's what. Can you imagine being a senior and having a daughter that keeps popping out babies in prison, that you feel responsible for? Most people wouldn't do anything, but these grandparents are stepping up to the plate and I commend them for that. For all you racist people who have been commenting here, go back and re-read the article. They mention 3 families, only one of which is part hispanic. Besides, wouldn't you rather the grandparents take care of the kids, regardless of race, than to put the kids into social services and make the tax-payers take care of them? I think that what these grandparents are doing is wonderful and I think that the Kinship program is a great program for helping them out!

Caught in the Middle wrote on Nov 8, 2006 9:48 AM:As a grandmother in this situation, I would like to refute the writer that I am not failing with another generation but trying to rescue them from a life with drug dependent parents, foster care and no future. Just because my grown son and daughter-in-law made a bad choice (regardless of his upbringing), don't fault me for loving my grandkids and stepping in to give them a chance.

John wrote on Nov 12, 2006 10:57 AM:GRANDPARENTS SHOULD NOT BE RAISING THER CHILDRENS KIDS.ANOTHER SICKNESS THAT SOCIETY SEEMS TO ACCEPT.WERE DID THE PRIDE GO FROM RAISING YOUR OWN KIDS?THE SIMPLE REASON THAT IM ALL FOR BIRTH CONTROL AND STERILIZATION.THERE ARE REASONS TO RAISE YOUR GRANDKIDS, BUT VERY FIEW.BUT!,SOMEONES GOT TO RAISE THE KIDS THEESE LOOSERS PLOP OUT. KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK.MABY YOU WILL BE REWARDED AS LONG AS YOU CAN KEEP THE PARENT OUT OF THE KIDS LIFE.A 15 YEAR OLD HAVING A BABY IS NOTHING TO BE PROUD OF.

Kellene wrote on Apr 12, 2007 7:48 PM:I cannot believe the comments on this topic of kinship care. I am a social worker who specializes in kinship care and one must gain an understanding on the root causes and derivatives of why a parent cannot raise his or her child. This society is based on stereotypes and mis-guidance and this is seen in the comments above. When a biological parent is unable to raise his or her child, a family member is vital in establishing secure attachments for the child. Before, one pass judgment on another take a good look at society as a whole. There are many reasons as to why an individual is unable to raise his or her children and one needs to have the education and knowledge about all the factors to why a person becomes emotionally and physically unavailable to one's own children. Grandparents have a tough job when taking on the role as a primary caretaker and our society does not support these courageous people.

SUE wrote on Feb 4, 2008 1:23 PM:I am shocked at the racist and predjudice responses I see here. First of all, it is the Caucasion population, then African Americans, that are the largest percentage of grandparents raising grandchildren (see American Survey 2006). Second, to grossly generalize shows the ignorance and lack of education of those making such ill-informed comments. Third, drugs, alcohol, THE MILITARY, and many other reasons cause this unfortunate circumstance - and whites have a great deal of trouble with all of these issues, as do many of us. REMEMBER: YOUR JUDGEMENT MEANS THAT YOU VIEW THE WORLD AS YOU ARE, RATHER THAN AS IT IS!
I am white, educated and I vote!!

First name only. Comments including last names, contact addresses, email addresses or phone numbers will be deleted. All comments are screened before they appear online, so please keep them brief. Comments reflect the views of those commenting and not necessarily those of the North County Times or its staff writers. Click here to view additional comment policies.

Submit Comment[-]

(optional)
   

Advertisement

Videos