Citizen groups seek more than review of shootings

By: JO MORELAND - Staff Writer | Thursday, February 15, 2007 10:53 PM PST

A decision by the state attorney general's office to revisit findings by the county district attorney in seven officer-involved shootings that occurred over the last two years in North County doesn't go far enough, leaders of two citizens groups said Thursday.

Spokesmen for El Grupo in North County, and the Coalition for Justice, a countywide group, said they had asked the attorney general's office for independent investigations of the seven shootings, and, in the future, for investigation of all officer-involved shootings in the county.

Instead, they say, they got what amounts to a paper review of the shooting investigations performed by the Sheriff's Department.

The groups, in a letter to the attorney general, said they had asked for the investigations because they were "concerned about police practices and apparent racial bias in light of incidents over the past 24 months."

One of the seven shootings cited by the groups involved Chargers linebacker Steve Foley, who is black, and six of the shootings involved Latino men in Vista.

While the state review is "a good first step," they said, they still want independent investigations by the attorney general's office of all officer-involved shootings in the county.

"The attorney general is an elected official," said the Rev. Arthur Cribbs Jr., co-founder of the Coalition for Justice. "We are using our voice and our presence, as voters in this state, to say, 'Do your job.' "

Gary Schons, senior assistant attorney general in charge of the San Diego regional office, said that his staff routinely reviews about six to 10 officer-involved shooting cases annually as well as assaults, sexual assaults and other cases for six Southern California counties.

About one of those every year is from San Diego County, Schons said.

"There is nothing extraordinary about this," he said of the review.

The only difference this time, said Schons, is that seven cases will be reviewed, all of them originally investigated by the Sheriff's Department.

Right now, each law enforcement agency in the county investigates its own officer-involved shootings, and the district attorney's office reviews those investigations to determine only whether the shootings were lawful or not.

Bill Flores, a retired San Diego County assistant sheriff who is a spokesman for El Grupo, said the district attorney's office has increasingly hired more former law-enforcement officers who are now involved in shooting reviews.

"Now what we're seeing is the people you're sending (to review officer-involved shooting investigations) are former cops," Flores said, explaining the group's concerns.

He said the citizen groups hope that the attorney general's review of the seven North County cases will include looking for a pattern in the shootings.

That number over two years is "alarmingly high" compared to similar small, semirural cities as well as other sheriff's stations in the county, Flores said.

"So, we think that this anomaly in Vista needs to be examined by a legal authority to determine whether that is a coincidence or there's any evidence of racial bias in the use of force or the application of the law in Vista," he said.

Flores said the groups did not send their concerns to the county Citizens Law Enforcement Review Board because it does not have the legal authority that the groups felt was needed to address the issues.

"We could have gone to the federal attorney general, but we felt the state attorney general was the more appropriate agency to take the appeal to," Flores said.

The citizens review board was created by a voter mandate in 1990 that started when an unarmed Vista man, Jeffrey Bray, was shot and killed by a sheriff's reserve deputy who mistook Bray for a suspect in a vehicle theft. The board is charged with reviewing civilian complaints of misconduct against sheriff's and probation department personnel, as well as deaths arising from the actions of those officers.

The board has no authority to discipline or fire those they investigate, but it can make recommendations if it finds wrongdoing or problems with policies and procedures.

Ernie Carrillo, the new president of the San Diego County Deputy Sheriff's Association, said that organization has no problem with the attorney general's office reviewing the seven cases.

"I don't think (independent investigations of any shootings) are necessary at this time," Carrillo added.

Chief Frank McCoy of the Oceanside Police Department said he "wouldn't be adverse" to independent investigations.

"We have nothing to hide in our shootings," McCoy said. "Any prosecuting agency that wants to get involved with that, we have no problem."

Sheriff Bill Kolender and District Attorney Bonnie Dumanis couldn't be reached for comment.

In a statement issued Wednesday, Dumanis said her office "is a transparent governmental agency and we welcome the review (of the seven North County shootings) by the Attorney General."

Capt. Glenn Revell, Sheriff's Department spokesman, said that agency hopes the attorney general's review of the seven shootings "will be valuable to all parties."

Two of the seven investigations, a Vista shooting last year and the Foley shooting, haven't been completed yet by the Sheriff's Department, said Schons. He said the review is expected to produce some answers within four months.

"We're going to review everything the district attorney looked at," but it won't be an investigation, he said. "We're not second-guessing, because we're reviewing for an abuse of discretion. The district attorney has wide discretion.

"If the review reveals a reasonable investigative avenue that wasn't pursued or another crime that could have been filed wasn't, that information will be sent to the district attorney's office," Schons said.

At a public forum earlier this month, Dumanis drew criticism when she noted that only two of about 148 officer-involved shootings were found unjustified over 10 years.

Contact staff writer Jo Moreland at (760) 740-3524 or jmoreland@nctimes.com.

Next Previous

Advertisement

16 comment(s)[-]Go to Top

Same old story wrote on Feb 15, 2007 11:54 PM:Fools names and fools faces always appear in public places. Old saying that is so true today. There are too many fools that have absolutely NOTHING to say but will say ANYTHING for publicity....and NCT will gladly provide the soapbox!!

These groups are a pain in the arse wrote on Feb 16, 2007 5:29 AM:and should be forced to PAY for all their demands. A person with even a small amount of intelligence would understand if you run from cops.... you going to get shot. I am tired of paying for ILLEGALS, now being forced to pay for their breaking the laws and these ILLEGAL immigrant rights groups and their wasteful demands.

Jeff wrote on Feb 16, 2007 6:05 AM:The last sentence of this article sums it all up. Why would the activists criticize Dumanis for noting that only two or about 148 OIS were found justified? Wouldn't they be more upset if it were 50 out of 148? Is the DA supposed to occasionally make an example out of a cop even though they did nothing wrong? Bill Flores and his band of clowns are on a witch hunt. They won't be happy until they get a sacrificial lamb. Mr. Flores would better serve his community by reaching out to young Hispanic gang members and drug users who will likely do something stupid enough to force a cop to shoot them. Perhaps he already knows it is a hopeless cause, and that is why he is focusing his ire on his former department.

Scott wrote on Feb 16, 2007 7:26 AM:What you asked for isn't enough? Then why did you ask for it? I just hope the Police and Sheriff departments don't throw down a scape goat to appease these groups. These groups don't have the strength to damage anyone's political career, they are not the majority and bowing down to them would bring out the majority in opposition of their racist ideology. Now Flores wants DA investigators to have no investigative background. Do you want them to just make decisions based on what would be best for the Hispanic community or should they still try to find the truth and assist the judicial community in serving the county.

Let the cops do their Job wrote on Feb 16, 2007 7:34 AM:In this day in age. Cops don't have much choice but to use deadly force. Today's criminals are much better armed than in the past. I don't want our officers to second guess themselves. When in doubt, shoot to kill!

Brett wrote on Feb 16, 2007 7:45 AM:What really is "alarmingly high" is the number of gang-bangers per capita you have in north county...7 shootings in 2 years isn't at all high considering this and other relevant facts so conveniently omitted in your political ad..in fact in my opinion its low.

Crazy wrote on Feb 16, 2007 8:29 AM:2 of 148 were unjustified. Thats sounds like an unreasonable number to me... Were the 2 politcial scapegoats or were they really unjustified? As for the complainers what would they say if the cops didn't respond or failed to act out of fear of prosecutors, who have no experience in police work, second guessing actions they make at life threatening sceens? If Flores had any police experience, he promoting little time on the streets, he would explain how dangerous police work can be!

Greg in Oceanside wrote on Feb 16, 2007 10:42 AM:The utter violence that permeates the Latino community on a daily basis is appalling. This cycle of violence will continue unless the so-called “leaders” of the Latino community step up to the plate. Where is El Grupo, NCLR, MEChA, etal when it comes to good citizenship? Seems to me these groups are missing a key piece of the puzzle; fixing the problems in the Latino community. If these groups spent more time straightening out the problems and trying to integrate into our culture than what is spent on defending Latino rights and finger pointing, we wouldn’t have the exorbitant crime and 55% dropout rate amongst Latinos in our community. Every day we hear about violent crime being committed by Latinos in all the communities here in San Diego County, and these advocacy groups are doing absolutely nothing to address this. It’s high-time they start acting like responsible organizations or people won’t take them too seriously until they do.

Ask wrote on Feb 16, 2007 11:07 AM:Think about this in the simplest of ways. Why were these people shot??? You dont get shot for just walking down the street, going shopping etc... You get shot for doing very stupid things and making the officers feel like their life is in danger. So take away the officers actions and look solely at what the dead people did, you ill understand.

I want wrote on Feb 16, 2007 12:20 PM:these citizen groups investigated!!! Who supports them and their "racist" agenda. Are they going to pay for these investigations? As a taxpayer, I don't WANT my tax dollar spent on investigations by outsiders whose whole agenda is to prosecute and persecute our law enforcement for doing their jobs. How many cops have been killed by these Hispanics, NONE of which were justified? Like others have said, I think El Grupo and others should spend their OWN money to remove guns and straighten out the Latino community if they want to stop shootings there. And Foley? yeah let's throw in ONE black guy who was obviously a justified shooting, to try and make a case.

Peter wrote on Feb 16, 2007 12:31 PM:The people in these groups need to spend more time guiding the young people in their communities to become good American citizens, to include respect for laws and those charged with enforcing those laws. If they really thought the truth was being hidden, they would ask all available agencies to review the cases not just one that they expect to be politically supportive. Instead of trying to paint themselves as victims and blaming law enforcement, how about being proactive in eliminating the violence that is routinely perpetrated against many in their communities by their own people.

I AGREE wrote on Feb 16, 2007 1:08 PM:I guess the illegals aren't used to our culture -- where the police keep the peace and protect the people. Instead they think that we should be more like their country where violence and corruption are rampant and police protect the criminals. Get out of my country and take your guns and criminal activites with you! Protection of the criminals does not belong here.

Jason wrote on Feb 16, 2007 5:38 PM:Hum… FIRST- these groups need to understand that the Supreme Court ruled that “internal investigations” are not subject for public review and this is perhaps the document (s ) that this group got. It is a packet explaining what I just said and the legal docs to support this fact. If these groups are seeking a challenge to the Supreme Court ruling then the appropriate place is the courts not the CA AG’s office. SECOND- the shootings between Chargers linebacker Steve Foley, and the Mexican documented drug dealers, gang members, caught robbing with a deadly weapon with a long list of criminal records will be considered separate and district. They cannot be mashed together into one investigation. All of the shootings were different Foley being perhaps the only one with merits the others are no brainers. THIRD- Rev. Arthur Cribbs is doing a great disservice and perhaps prejudicing Foleys civil case whereby the promise future jury will automatically connect Foley in an unfavorable light based on the connection between the Vista drugs, gangs, theft, arm robberies etc…, what a shame.

Amanda wrote on Feb 16, 2007 5:46 PM:OK NCT did I miss something what does Chief Frank McCoy of the Oceanside Police Department have to do with the Vista sheriffs shootings? Is he a member of the BOARD that investigated the sheriff’s shootings? Please explain what Oceanside’s OPD have to do with the Sheriffs aren’t they two separate entities?

Wiley wrote on Feb 16, 2007 6:40 PM:If Mr. Flores is looking for a pattern, all he has to do is take a look at the Townsite crime statistics, or read the paper. If the Latino community disrespects the laws of this country continuously and fails to educate their children in proper, law abiding behavior, then they have no right or reason to complain when one of them gets shot while committing a crime. Mr. Flores should spend his energy teaching English and values to the Latino community, something that's sorely missing. And if they feel treated so poorly and misunderstood: they know the way home.

Do you get it? wrote on Feb 16, 2007 7:09 PM:You know caucasions are shot everyday but I do not see anyone forming groups to investigate their shootings. I am so tired of the hispanic groups and the black groups crying racism. This has to STOP! It is their actions that get them shot, plain and simple.

First name only. Comments including last names, contact addresses, e-mail addresses or phone numbers will be deleted. Attempts to misrepresent your identity or impersonate any person will not be approved. All comments are screened before they appear online, so please keep them brief. Comments reflect the views of those commenting and not necessarily those of the North County Times or its staff writers. Click here to view additional comment policies.

Submit Comment[-]

(optional)
   

Advertisement

Videos