Survey: Strong support for legalizing illegal immigrants among local voters

By: EDWARD SIFUENTES - Staff Writer | Wednesday, June 20, 2007 9:43 AM PDT

A coalition of groups supporting immigrant rights released a poll Tuesday that appears to turn conventional wisdom about immigration attitudes in the county on its head.

The survey of 600 likely voters in the county said 61 percent of respondents agreed with an immigration plan to legalize millions of illegal immigrants similar to the one offered in the Senate immigration bill. That bill was shelved by Senate leaders recently but supporters plan to bring it back to the Senate floor.

Critics said Tuesday that the questions were biased. The survey was conducted between May 29 and June 3 by Santa Monica-based Fairbank, Maslin, Maullin & Associates, a firm with a long list of Democratic clients. It has a margin of error of plus or minus 4 percent.

Supporters of immigration reform said the poll shows most people want a policy that legalizes illegal immigrants.

"I think this poll shows there is a silent majority that believes we need practical solutions," said Andrea Guerrero, chairwoman of the Immigrant Rights Consortium of San Diego County, which commissioned the survey.

The coalition includes about 25 labor, legal and religious groups promoting comprehensive immigration reform.

Critics, including a spokesman for Rep., Brian Bilbray, R-Solana Beach, said the survey does not accurately reflect voters' views on immigration reform.

"If that were the case, Brian would not have been elected," said Kurt Bardella, a spokesman for Bilbray, one of the staunchest opponents of the Senate immigration bill.

Bilbray, who was elected last year on an anti-illegal immigration platform, is one of five congressional representatives for San Diego County. He is chairman of the Immigration Reform Caucus, a group of lawmakers seeking stricter immigration policies.

Three of the county's congressional representatives are Republicans who are among the most outspoken lawmakers on illegal immigration. They include Rep. Duncan Hunter, R-El Cajon, a presidential candidate with a platform of stronger national and border security, and Rep. Darrell Issa, R-Vista, who recently joined Bilbray's caucus.

The countywide survey also found that:

  • 75 percent of those surveyed favored legalizing illegal immigrant children who went to school in the country;

  • 70 percent said they favor a guest-worker program that allows workers to stay temporarily in the country.

    Moreover, the poll said that a majority of respondents, 52 percent, oppose building a fence the entire length of the border with Mexico.

    Steven Camarota, research director for the Washington, D.C.-based Center for Immigration Studies, which supports stricter immigration policies, said the wording of the poll's questions was biased.

    "It's a good advocacy poll," Camarota said. "I don't see any neutral questions in the poll. It seems those who designed it have very strong views on immigration and tried as hard as possible to get the results they wanted."

    Camarota said phrases such as "paying fines and back taxes, proving good moral character and learning English" in the question about legalizing illegal immigrants, are misleading.

    "These are fun questions," he said. "Since the Senate does not actually require back taxes be paid. It just says you have to show you paid taxes."

    However, David Mermin, a partner at Lake Research Partners, a Washington-based polling company that also has many Democrat clients, said the questions are fair since they closely resemble the Senate proposal. He said most polling firms work for one side or another, but that doesn't mean their methods are invalid.

    "We don't serve our clients by giving them bad data," Mermin said. Giving them a full picture of public opinion allows clients to "be effective advocates for their position."

    Guerrero said not all results were favorable to the group, which she said was evidence of the survey's attempt to be fair. She said the group paid for the survey with $26,000 worth of donations from private individuals.

    Most respondents, 54 percent, said they supported authorizing local law enforcement to enforce federal immigration laws. Respondents were also closely divided when asked whether they would support city ordinances banning landlords from renting to illegal immigrants. Forty-seven percent said they favored them while 45 percent opposed them.

    "We wanted to show the good, the bad and the ugly," Guerrero said.

    -- Contact staff writer Edward Sifuentes at (760) 740-3511 or esifuentes@nctimes.com.

    Next Previous
  • Advertisement

    161 comment(s)[-]Go to Top

    Reardon wrote on Jun 19, 2007 10:34 PM:One needs to read no further than the first part of the first sentence: "A coalition of groups supporting immigrant rights released a poll..." Do I believe a poll released by government telling me that government is doing well? Do I believe a poll released by environmentalist special interest groups telling me that everyone loves the California Condor as a beautiful bird? Do I ...

    Federal Rental Ban! wrote on Jun 19, 2007 10:38 PM:The poll shows that a majority of respondents want a Federal ban on landlords renting to illegal immigrants. Renting property is a business. The business relationship between landlord and tenant is a long term relationship lasting for months or years. Asking a landlord to spend a few minutes to verify residency status using something like an I-9 form, much like employers are now required to do, is not a big deal except to the illegal immigrant who is trying to blend into the existing community undetected. For the last 20 years, I have had to provide documents to my employer to be able to work. Fake documents is the currency of criminals and are no excuse for not implementing effective policies, such as a Federal rental ban. Foreign nationals do not have the right to invade the US and reside here without consequence because they claim some civil right violation. That is a perversion of civil rights. Every citizen of the US, including landlords, should welcome the opportunity to assist in the effort to address the problem of illegal immigration.

    YES!!!!! wrote on Jun 19, 2007 10:39 PM:That's what I say....Legalize!!!! Amnesty Now!!!!

    Concerned-1 wrote on Jun 19, 2007 11:22 PM:The truth comes out, amnesty is popular. So all the ranting and raving by the [opponents] was just a lot of BS.

    Shovel it wrote on Jun 20, 2007 12:01 AM:This is total insanity. Who are these 61% of 600 idiots that responded, I didn't see this poll. Was it a closed poll, only to private pollers, what is this??!! They are just trying to shove this down our throats, regardless of the madness it will create. Think of the hundreds and thousands of illegals that will pour in and fully take over what's left. Caifornia will turn into Calimexico, just you wait. Every one will have to speak spanish, since it will be the national language. Every city will turn into slums, and crime will go out of control. Why does the government want to bend over and give these illegals citizenship, why, what for, so they vote for the democrates?? Yeah sure!! This should not even be issue at all. Stop hiring the illegals and they will go back with their tails between their legs.

    Hogwash wrote on Jun 20, 2007 12:02 AM:read the name ask non illegals what they would vote for not illegals what a crock

    Absolutely Hilarious! wrote on Jun 20, 2007 12:05 AM:I know of not one person who is in favor of amnesty and fast tracked citizenship. What a crock!

    lucky88 wrote on Jun 20, 2007 12:23 AM:Federal rentals ban making landlords as ICE agents ? LOL You guys got to be kidding me ! What next guys, Chinese restaurants and Pizzerias must see the customers greencards or US passports before selling them chicken Lo Mein or Pepperoni pizza ? Yeah right ! Business is business, why I must ban "illegal" immigrants to rent my properties according to my terms, they care my properties well, they pay the rent, they don't overcrowd them, they are not sex offenders or hardcore criminals, I don't care about the rest. Common folks, get real. Why airlines must reject those paying customers also. Terrorists can be US citizens and legal residents and they may posses real IDs and passports. This anti immigration crowd needs to educate themselves. Immigration laws won't protect American jobs. Learn something, speak multi languages get educated. Jobs can be outsourced and replaced with robots and machines. Whine and whine is not the smart solution. The problem with "illegal" immigrants can be solved easily. Make them legal then !, and US citizenships must be preserved to those who can show the most merits. And promise no welfare. We don't want parasites living in this country whether their illegal immigrants nor lazy US citizens.

    NCT slow news day?? wrote on Jun 20, 2007 12:31 AM:Edward whips out his keyboard twice in one day to tell us the bogus Immigrant Rights Consortium of San Diego County had a bogus poll conducted. EXCELLENT REPORTING!!

    no credibility wrote on Jun 20, 2007 1:58 AM:nobody I speak with wants to legalize any illegal immigrant period. What a farce and waste of time this story is.

    Dickey wrote on Jun 20, 2007 2:00 AM:Hogwash! Don't believe a word this says... Reardon is right. This "poll" was probably taken outside of a labor camp. No wonder it's in favor of legalizing immigrants!

    Ron wrote on Jun 20, 2007 4:21 AM:Exactly my thought, Reardon!

    KARL wrote on Jun 20, 2007 4:43 AM:NO AMNESTY AT ALL -illegal workers undercutting American workers, hired by lawbreakers American employers. I vote to deport both. The employers are also guilty.Massive deportation now! Do what's right for America!

    Mike in Oceanside wrote on Jun 20, 2007 5:12 AM:Build the fence, Enforce the laws already on the books, hold employers accountable AND THEN YOU CAN TALK ABOUT LEAGLIZING WHOM EVER YOU WANT.

    Hal wrote on Jun 20, 2007 5:24 AM:How come he did not survey "legal voters" and not "likely voters"? Just another spin job by this guy.

    Margaret wrote on Jun 20, 2007 5:58 AM:I think the conductors of this poll need to look closely at their control group. Reardon said it all!!

    Questions?? wrote on Jun 20, 2007 6:39 AM:For once, it would be nice to know exactly what the "poll" questions were, how they were phrased and who was surveyed. Then we would need to know the breakdown of how each of these questions were answered. Usually these pollsters are "preaching to the choir", in other words, selecting subjects who are likely to answer in a way that supports their view. Then they try to pass off the results as legitimate. NCT--let's see some effort on your part to dig a little deeper.

    mr fixit wrote on Jun 20, 2007 6:45 AM:I suport the presidents bill. It is not practical to deport masses of people in some kind of midnight roundup.

    Todd wrote on Jun 20, 2007 6:49 AM:This Sifuentes person is quite bias in the articles he chooses to present. He clearly has a pro-illegal alien agenda.

    Brad wrote on Jun 20, 2007 6:56 AM:No one I talk to wants another 12 million law-breaking illegal immigrants given amnesty...we want them all deported and they can get in line with the rest of the legal immigrants who respect the sovereignty of the U.S. That and the fact that amnesty will end up costing U.S. taxpayers 1 TRILLION dollars in benefits. The poll was done by immigrants rights groups who, in actuality, are supporting those who break U.S. laws.

    I talk to ALOT of people and no one I know is for this bill.... wrote on Jun 20, 2007 7:02 AM:Rodger Hedgecock read OUT LOUD yesterday the "questions" in this "unbiased" poll. Talk about a CROCK.----I've said a hundred times; put it to a VOTE and you'll see another Prop. 187 result (from LEGAL REGISTERED voters, by the way and not from illegals with forged documents).----I don't know where Miss Andrea reads, but there is unbelievable overwhelming opposition to legalizing millions of people, and what's surprising is that it's from across the U.S., not just border states.---If support for legalization was a truth, then WHY are there over, what, 90 cities at last count who are writing legislation to curb illegal immigration, putting it out to voters regarding rental laws, etc.?----Sorry, but there's an INCREDIBLE amount of American citizens out there who aren't interested in giving up America's sovereignty. THAT's the tsunami the open-border advocates need to think about.----My husband did not serve in Vietnam nor my son in Kuwait & Iraq to quietly let our country die without a fight. You've gotta be kidding me. The open-border foks who think socialism "is a good thing" underestimates its opponents.

    My Suggestion.... wrote on Jun 20, 2007 7:10 AM:Take your own poll in your own area and have them report on your findings.

    Mike wrote on Jun 20, 2007 7:12 AM:I don't know of any voters that favor amenesty...I can't believe this poll is anywhere near correct..

    fedup wrote on Jun 20, 2007 7:13 AM:not a good poll, was determined to make it look like everyone wants ILLEGALS to be here from its'conception. ILLEGAL ALIENS are merely criminals that have broken the law and will continue to break laws. The simplest fix is to eliminate the jobs, places to live and free social services to anyone that is an ILLEGAL ALIEN. They will self-deport to wher they came from.

    Ed Sifuentes has absolutely wrote on Jun 20, 2007 7:14 AM:NO credibility with me. I know of NOT ONE PERSON who supports amnesty for ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS. Most people consider them criminals for entering our country illegally and want them DEPORTED. I saw the headline and I KNEW he wrote the article. What world does he live in? Oh yes the NCT world of hogwash!

    Reality Check wrote on Jun 20, 2007 7:21 AM:Don't like the truth? Call it hogwash, insult the reporter, stick your fingers in your ears and yell "I can't hear you!"

    Quit surveying wrote on Jun 20, 2007 7:24 AM:ILLEGAL ALIENS! 80% of polls taken across America, prove this poll is a political lie. How do you tell when the pollsters and the politicans are lying? Their mouths are moving!

    Laughter wrote on Jun 20, 2007 7:36 AM:Hahahahahahaha! Nine comments above me. I'm number 10. Two comments appear to be pro-"legalize breaking the law and reward doing so". One of those is clearly sarcasm. So the real "poll" is that 10% favor amnesty and 90% are against.

    Is this a joke? wrote on Jun 20, 2007 7:46 AM: Ok Edward I am a registered Democrat, Hispanic and I know for a certainty that EVERY SINGLE person that I know who lives LEGALLY in the North County DOES NOT support the amnesty of 12 million illegal.

    Balderdash! wrote on Jun 20, 2007 8:28 AM:This is nothing but a pantload! So the polling firm has democrat clientele. Look who is trumpeting the results. We all know how easily polls can be skewed merely through the manner in which the questions are phrased. This is a crock! WE DON'T NEED REFORM, BUT RATHER ENFORCEMENT!! So let's enforce the law. Round up the illegal aliens and ship 'em out. It can be done. Just do a websearch of "Operation Wetback" which was carried out during the Eisenhower administration.

    Patriot wrote on Jun 20, 2007 8:28 AM:Let us see the questions exactly as they were asked. Did they address any specific provision in the Senate bill or any of the amendments offered, or were they simply general questions phrased to generate support for the "immigrant"?

    Filled with Hate? wrote on Jun 20, 2007 8:39 AM:that's what it seems, just take a look at today's letters to the editor. A small minority ... filled with hate so this poll is very interesting - a small, imperfect indication of what most people believe. Let's find a compromise that allows immigrants to add to the economy of our country, stops an influx without a fence and provides opportunities to learn English.

    Sam wrote on Jun 20, 2007 8:41 AM:Illegal is illegal! There is a propper procedure to enter this country, just as it is to enter there country. The rules for employers, should be the same for landlords, and all people. The country is for and by all AMERICANS'; not illegal aliens!

    Puzzled wrote on Jun 20, 2007 8:43 AM:Where did this coalition group find its people to poll? Did they call everyone known to be illegal? I talk to hundreds of people every week and have not found one yet who favors the absurd bill that has failed so far in Congress. The survey itself is biased, confusing and misleading, and only those who don't listen or read are apt to agree with it.

    Joe wrote on Jun 20, 2007 8:44 AM:Why is the NC Times printing an article from a special interest group touting its own special interest? Anyone knows that a poll is only as meaningful as the impartiality of the pollster. This is simply not journalism.

    Concerned-1 wrote on Jun 20, 2007 8:48 AM:Again with the bogus post. Just like the poll in the story, and the writer of the story, the Concerned-1 post at 11:22 shows the true colors of the source. And BTW, if 60 percent of Americans really do want amnesty for illegal criminals, we have dumbed down much more than even the NCT would have us believe. I think I'm going to change my Handle

    Likely Voters? wrote on Jun 20, 2007 8:51 AM:Who exactly are "likely voters"? Why use a survey population of likely voters when there are so many of us "registered voters" who can be polled? Who really cares what a person who is likely to vote thinks about illegal immigration? And, I think anyone could find 600 illegals who would be likely voters that think they deserve free citizenship, without penalty and all the benefits they already receive!

    Zygo wrote on Jun 20, 2007 8:52 AM:A similar bill and the same bill are two different creatures. By changing small items in a survey you can get a positive response and then show support for something that is not supported. Unless the poll was presenting the same conditions, then it is worthless unless the bill would change to what the poll was...and then the question would be who was polled...was it a true cross representation. My guess is it was not.

    Shows that, as in most things, both parties are out of touch wrote on Jun 20, 2007 8:53 AM:The problem is that both sides, of just about any issue, are extremists, and tha tis who shapes the debate and the great middle gets unrepresented. Good, sane, people agree with some of the ideas on both sides. I voted for Bilbray, but I favor a much saner immigration policy, including an amnesty for the otherwise law abiding current illegals who have been contributing to their communities, building and cleaning our houses, building businesses (often their own), paying taxes, and obeying the law. I also support much stronger border enforcement, but much more easily crossed borders (more crossings, more agents). Bilbray got elected because, despite the massive take-down of a lot of her course materials and prior writings, plenty of people knew that Busby was from the far left Feminazi branch of the Democrat party. She didn't represent even the typical north county democrat, who is more of a chilled out eco-liberal than a gender rights activist. I still think that we have to secure the border before we give amnesty, but we can also fix a lot of what is wrong with our immigration in the meantime.

    Frank wrote on Jun 20, 2007 8:55 AM:I'm surprised the Times printed this blatant opinion piece as news.

    CR wrote on Jun 20, 2007 8:55 AM:It is amazing that anyone would actually believe a survey done for several pro-illegal groups by a Democrat-leaning hole-in-the-wall survey company. The true results would be the exact opposite, but you can warp anything to get the results you want. I would guess the real results would be 80% opposed to legalizing the illegals. It is worse than just hogwash--this poll was something you wouldn't want to step in on the sidewalk!

    lets vote wrote on Jun 20, 2007 8:55 AM:Okay if its so popular then how about we vote on it in when we vote for president? Lets make it an amendment to the constitution. Oh wait; we won't need a constitution then. No, better the lawmakers vote on it and then tell us its what we said we wanted.

    RCH wrote on Jun 20, 2007 9:00 AM:Surveys can be so bias as to obtain any desired result. All you need to do is put yourself in an area that will cause you to get YOUR desired result. If a true cross sectional survey was taken, I would wager that the results would be a higher percentage for the opposing view. Again, it is NOT a racial issue, it is a LEGAL issue, so please don't try to play that card.

    Who? wrote on Jun 20, 2007 9:00 AM:I dont know a single person who wants amnesty in any form. Who did these people poll? If you dont think this poll was extremely biased you are ignorant and naive'.

    So Cal Native wrote on Jun 20, 2007 9:02 AM:See! The majority of the blogs in any of these forums are actually the minority of the AMERICAN views. Get a life!

    To Absolutely Hilarious wrote on Jun 20, 2007 9:05 AM:I know you don't know me but I am all for Amnesty.

    singer wrote on Jun 20, 2007 9:18 AM:"The survey of 600 likely voters in the county said 61 percent of respondents agreed with an immigration plan to legalize millions of illegal immigrants..." Let me see, they (the people in the poll) were all hispanic, and none had green cards. They are only "likely voters" IF such a bill is passed. Your story doesn't hold water! MOST AMERICANS DON'T WANT ILLEGAL IMMIGRATION!! LEGALIZING ILLEGALS DOESN'T SOLVE THE PROBLEM - IT JUST CREATES A GREATER PROBLEM!! Sifuentes, you have lost your credibility!

    You are all racist wrote on Jun 20, 2007 9:36 AM:As someone who is American born and therefore American but of immigrant parents (yes illegal from Mexico) your views are not acceptable.

    Rigged wrote on Jun 20, 2007 9:40 AM:Of course this poll is rigged much like the Presidential election results were in Florida. Even people I would think might be for amnesty aren't. The pastor in our family believes our laws need to be obeyed. If you want to help other people from other countries go to their country and help them.

    Bogus Poll wrote on Jun 20, 2007 9:42 AM:Lets see if we took a poll of all the Christians in Iraq afraid of being killed by a Shite or Sunni muslim it would probalby be a very high percentage. Now if you take a poll of those already in favor of amnesty don't you think you would get positive results. Take a Poll of Americans seeing their neighborhoods and cities become third world crowded, loud and dirty and I think you would have an overwhelming percentage in favor of deporting.

    Mike wrote on Jun 20, 2007 9:42 AM:Come on, NC TImes, you can do better reporting than this. This sophomoric article shows the reporter's obvious bias in favor of amnesty for illegals. This reporter got way carried away suggesting this so-called "survey" changes conventional wisdom about granting amnesty to illegal aliens. I could have gotten similar survey results taking polls at day laborer sites too.

    I Hate Socialists wrote on Jun 20, 2007 9:59 AM:When the Minuteman release a poll that shows 90% of US Citizens want illegals to get te hell out of our country, do you think every news agency out there would publish it like it had any crediblity at all? Just proves again that the media (wannabe)journalists are THE lobbying organization for the commie left.

    Les wrote on Jun 20, 2007 9:59 AM:Mr SIFUENTES, your article, the poll on which it was based, and the entire premise you present in it,is absolutly wrong. It is a wonder this newspaper chose to print it at all, never mind to represent it as anything other than opinion. What do you think shut down the Senate when the amnesty bill was up for a vote, public opinion. Look at all the view points expressed on this newspaper blog whenever this subject comes up. Public opinion favors enforcement of the law! The only thing amnesty will do will be to cause millions more to cross the border illegally, just as it did in the 1980's. Build the fence, conduct interior enforcment, punish employers who employ illegal aliens, and then we can address the issues involving the millions who've broken the law and are already here.

    Fran wrote on Jun 20, 2007 10:43 AM:No amnesty!

    Mars wrote on Jun 20, 2007 10:52 AM:To "You are all Racist"-We have the right to our opinions and our own views thank you! Also, since your parents are illegal did they use up as much as they could on the welfare system and every other freebie program out there that us legal taxpayers pay for?

    We are not racist when wrote on Jun 20, 2007 10:53 AM:we do not desire to legalize CRIMINALS and playing the race card is NOT going to work. I too am a Latina and I DO NOT support amnesty!

    Ferdinand wrote on Jun 20, 2007 11:04 AM:How come the people ranting about this article's written surveys have not done so in the rasmussen and lou dobbs polls? Is it not weird that people who uses the A word really meant A=R = racists? or No brainers?. Do they believe only in what will appease their twisted brains?. I find that this group don't use their brains at all, they are like zombies willing to follow their leaders sweet tongues. They obediently follow self proclaimed cnn media king dobbs married to a mestiza mexican who can't even remember her roots. They follow the tancredos, the billbrays, session and de mint who are bent on destroying the republican party to advance their rotten ego's. I once was a conservative, but mind you, I use my tiny brains a lot. I'm fed up with these few power thirsty republicans. How come the democrats don't have any problem with immigration ranters? Are republicans alone in not getting the picture on what is in the table? I suspect most of the writers in the internet are not conservatives at all, they are egoists, humbags, real scumbags of this country. They are neither racists nor bigots, but parrots repeating words of their masters. Everyday, they talk the same, talk, talk, always talking of the same thing without thinking of what will happen to our beloved country. May God bless us all, including the parrots and the racists.

    Three kinds of lies wrote on Jun 20, 2007 11:05 AM:Lies, damn lies and statistics. By the way we don't need to deport them all in one day. It has taken 21 years for it to get this bad. 21 years since the last comprehensive immigration reform. So we start enforcing the law and maybe in 21 years we will have it back under control. Maybe then we can think about a guest worker program or increasing the number of people who can legally get citizenship. A wall will never work. They will find a way over, under or around. Interior enforcement is the only answer.

    Jorge wrote on Jun 20, 2007 11:07 AM:A Sifuentes article...'nuff said.

    Billy wrote on Jun 20, 2007 11:26 AM:write, email,fax, or phone your congressman, tell them what you really think!

    Dave Of The Desert wrote on Jun 20, 2007 11:28 AM:Looks like a Cal State San Marcos Poll. Bogus!!

    simpleUSA wrote on Jun 20, 2007 11:30 AM:How come the people ranting about this article's written surveys have not done so in the rasmussen and lou dobbs polls? Are the extreme left and right wings biased too?. Do they believe only in what will appease their twisted brains?. I find that this group don't use their brains at all, they are like zombies willing to follow their leaders sweet tongues. They obediently follow self proclaimed cnn media king dobbs They follow the tancredos, the billbrays, session and de mint who are bent on destroying the republican party to advance their rotten ego's. I once was a conservative, but mind you, I use my tiny brains a lot. I'm fed up with these few power thirsty republicans. How come the democrats don't have any problem with immigration ranters? Are republicans alone in not getting the picture on what is in the table? I suspect most of the individual commentators in the internet are not conservatives at all, they are egoists, humbags, real scumbags of this country. They are neither racists nor bigots, but parrots repeating words of their masters. Everyday, they talk the same, talk, talk, always talking of the same thing without thinking of what will happen to our beloved country. Have you all thought about what's best for our country. Have you thought about the consequences of allowing/ or deporting this illegal immigrants yet? Don't throw words such as traitors for those who wants to fix this mess, think of yourselves first if you have done any good to our country. May God guide us, and bless us all, including the parrots and the racists.

    Ferdinand wrote on Jun 20, 2007 11:55 AM:Billbray won not because he is anti immigrant. He scared people on the campaign trail. This is what politicians do when they need votes. PLease read his campaign archives. He will know it when he goes for re-election This article isn't biased at all. It explaines the feelings of both sides. Not like what cnn does, they only show what is good for their interests. Mr absolutely hilarious, I think you are a loner who doese not mingle with other people. Ask your other neighbor and he will tell you there's a lot of voters who backs this bill. Name it amnesty if you want. The bill is not amnesty to me, I consider it to be a saviour when I retire, and a help to my children in the future.

    Greg in Oceanside wrote on Jun 20, 2007 12:08 PM:Ed Sifuentes is at it again. Trying to "convince" everyone that the majority of American citizens are in favor of amnesty or legalizing illegal aliens. I'm wondering what "600" people were polled. I hate to break the news to Ed, but this is not a good survey or accurate representation of the true statistics. The overwhelming majority of American citizens do not support amnesty or legalizing illegal aliens. Do us all a favor Ed, do your homework and get accurate data before you print erroneous information.

    John wrote on Jun 20, 2007 12:11 PM:I believe the survey to be wrought with ambiguity and quite slanted to portray the average North County citizen as favoring amnesty. Special interest group surveys are structured to produce results in line with their agenda. And just where was this "survey" taken? Around the North Santa Fe area of Vista? I don't recall any articles by Mr. Sifuentes about those in opposition to illegal immigration.

    Simple USA wrote on Jun 20, 2007 12:29 PM:Who do you follow. The pope, the Catholic Church or some of these other liberals and I will use traitors if I so well please. There are laws that are in place is that simple enough USA. Why should any of us follow or obey the laws when others from other Latin American countries can so flagrantly break them. Why should we pay taxes, to support people who break our laws. If you want to live in anarchy simple USA you only have to go to some of the Mexican cities controlled by the drug dealers. Not only do they illegally come into our country but they also get phony documents to work here. Many of them work for cash and pay no taxes. We don't have to deport all 12 million at once. That is ludicrous. From attrition by busting the cheaters at the work place we can start deporting a million or so a year. And I do call those who actively support breaking the laws of our government a traitor. Read it as you see it.

    Billy is right wrote on Jun 20, 2007 12:40 PM:Regardless of how you feel about this issue, your time is wasted commenting here. Contact your representatives & tell them how you feel & how you expect them (YOUR representatives) to vote. Forget about the labels and party affiliations, write to them about the issues that are MOST important to you and explain WHY those issues are important. Add that REGADLESS of your party affiliation, in the future, you will support & vote for those canidates that you feel will truly represent you. Polls like this (actually most polls) are designed to let the uninformed public (and those who don't even bother to vote) believe that there's nothing they can do to affect what happens.

    kc wrote on Jun 20, 2007 1:15 PM:If we really want to know what the truth is, lets have a "poll", an election. Lets have a special election to see what the American citizens truly think. Like Prop 187, like Gray Davis recall, lets let the REAL citizens speak. No one will do it. They'll say its too costly. Someone should draft a special election, let the CITIZENS decide whether or not these people stay, not the politicians. Let the Americans decide what to do. Let the Americans enforce it. What does America say? My guess is an overwhelming bye-bye.

    sis wrote on Jun 20, 2007 1:21 PM:I just did my own survey in my neighborhood it was 100% against amnesty .was this taken in t.j.

    Santa Monica.... wrote on Jun 20, 2007 1:25 PM:Santa Monica is extremely liberal allowing street people laying all over the place on city streets. Take a poll in San Diego county closer to the border and see the negative results. Can you imagine all these illegal people bringing over their families who can't make it in Mexico, uneducated and unemployed? You think we have major problems now as taxpayers, just wait....

    Patriot wrote on Jun 20, 2007 1:29 PM:Visit the Immigrant Rights Consortium of San Diego County web site and you will see liberal use of the terms "unauthorized migrant", "newcomer", and "undocumented worker". I couldn't even find their poll questions on their web site, but can only suppose the questions were seasoned with similar euphemisms to invoke the desired response.

    reality checker wrote on Jun 20, 2007 1:40 PM:Why not include the questions from the 'poll' in the article? Any poll can have a desired result based on the questions asked.

    Laughing at the Poll wrote on Jun 20, 2007 1:45 PM:Why does the NCT publish such obvious bull? Of course there pollsters are going to release a poll that fits their agenda.

    All for it wrote on Jun 20, 2007 2:08 PM:Okay if its so popular then how about we vote on it in when we vote for president? Lets make it an amendment to the constitution. Oh wait; we won't need a constitution then. No, better the lawmakers vote on it and then tell us its what we said we wanted.856

    All for it wrote on Jun 20, 2007 2:08 PM:Okay if its so popular then how about we vote on it in when we vote for president? Lets make it an amendment to the constitution. Oh wait; we won't need a constitution then. No, better the lawmakers vote on it and then tell us its what we said we wanted.

    To: You are all racist at 9:36----- wrote on Jun 20, 2007 2:10 PM:Huh. Views from legal, law-abiding, taxpaying Americans are "not acceptable" to you. Interesting. So, you get to enjoy the benefits of America (including our precious citizenship) as a result of your parents violating our immigration laws, and OUR views are unacceptable to you? Your arrogance is quite unbecoming.----May I ask if you've ever read Mexico's immigration laws? I wonder how your parents would have felt if people from other countries, say Darfur, for example, arrived en masse to Mexico when your parents were still living there.----Calling people racist because we want our laws respected and obeyed defies logic. As an American citizen, do YOU respect our laws? Or are you okay with document-forging and identity theft? Just wondering.

    Funny wrote on Jun 20, 2007 2:45 PM:how 80% of Americans across America are against illegal aliens being here, but paid pollsters will say anything that their employers want the public to hear. Maybe a law in truth in polling should be adopted?

    Amnesty Now! wrote on Jun 20, 2007 3:31 PM:I don't want to repay my student loans. I also want to stop paying taxes. If you don't support giving me tax and debt amnesty, you are a racist. Also, nearly 80% of the voters in San Diego County support granting me debt and tax amnesty. If you don't agree with the 80% majority, you are an extremist.

    Griff wrote on Jun 20, 2007 3:34 PM:Taking a biased group of 600 Dems speaks for whole county. PROPAGANDA!

    Wait a dang wrote on Jun 20, 2007 4:24 PM:moment here! 1984 Big Brother Propaganda is over isn't it? Oh wait my mistake doublespeak is still being used by politicans and the media.

    Old Surfer Dude wrote on Jun 20, 2007 4:38 PM:Well, I don't agree with this new immigration policy, nor with amnesty for millions of illegal aliens. But, when I read articles like this, and read some of these blogs, it seems inevitable that the bill will pass. Afterall, we really don't have any say in what happens. The new world paradigm has already been planned and it's going to make the rich richer and the rest of us...well we better learn Spanish. It won't be pretty that's for sure. Think TJ and you will see the future.

    More NCT propoganda wrote on Jun 20, 2007 4:47 PM:I didn't take this poll. All of the polls I've seen overwhelmingly say just the opposite. This is BS, not buying it and no one else is either.

    Senator Snort wrote on Jun 20, 2007 5:21 PM:I plan to vote for this bill. I really don't see what you people are ranting about. In my neighborhood, everyone speaks English, our kids get the best educations in prep school, our jobs and retirement funds are secure, there are no gangs, and my neighbors' businesses are profitable with all this cheap labor. Maybe if you all just worked harder and stopped complaining you too could become a Senator someday.

    morgan wrote on Jun 20, 2007 5:53 PM:What a joke....the story I read before this was that this poll was taken by a pro illegal immgrant group

    Disgusted wrote on Jun 20, 2007 6:27 PM:What kind of blatant propoganda is this? What poll? Sounds like it was conducted in Mexico. All these alleged polls that "support this bill", and I've never seen one of them, nor has anybody I know. Fact is, over 80 percent of American Citizens want no part of this bill. They want no part of amnesty or a pathway to citizenship. They remember how we got "duped" back in 1986 with the first amnesty of 4.1 illegals. Well, we now have between 15-25 million illegals (nobody knows for sure) and wide open, porous borders. We're not going to get suckered again. And, we do have a say in what happens. It's called civil unrest. Civil disobedience. Anarchy. Revolt. The politicians don't have the final word. We The People Do. I for one will not sit back and watch these career politicians, and pro-illegal advocates give this country away to Mexico. We've got border patrol agents being shot at, rammed with cars, hit with bricks, fire bombed, and the latest tactic of illegals setting forest fires in AZ to deter border patrol agents. This is a hostile invasion. And we're going to reward these illegal creeps? Wake up, Washington D.C. and get your collective heads out of your keesters!

    Art wrote on Jun 20, 2007 6:43 PM:My Grandparents stood in line at Ellis Island!! My wife's ancestors (Salazars of New Mexico) swore allegents to Gen. Kearney in 1846 on his way to California!! Both families have been good honest US Citizens ever since. NO AMNESTY!!!!

    Paul wrote on Jun 20, 2007 7:00 PM:I wonder if the NCT published this to intentionally stir the pot amongst the electorate? It sure caused me to fire off another email to congresmen and the senators. If that is their reason, they sure acheived their goal.

    Pappy wrote on Jun 20, 2007 8:28 PM:I agree with -Funny- when he says "how 80% of Americans across America are against illegal aliens being here". The difference is I, and the majority of the people polled say, give them amnesty, make them legal. Problem solved. We also say, and this is more important than the millions already here illegally, lock our borders down tight, tight, tight. Don't let any immigrants from any nation in without completing the complete immigration process.

    DAS Temecula wrote on Jun 20, 2007 10:07 PM:I agree with Absolutly Hilarious! What survey? What a CROCK. Fed up...What I read 98% of people are against what Bush is trying to push down our throats.

    Just not right - wrote on Jun 20, 2007 11:19 PM:Once again they took another poll and I wasn't invited. It's just not right.

    Skip wrote on Jun 20, 2007 11:58 PM:CURRENT AOL POLL : Do you support the immigration bill? NO 75% YES 25% Total Votes: 132,201

    Skip wrote on Jun 21, 2007 12:05 AM:It is not right to do the survey with Illegal Aliens and then add credibility to the poll by publishing it a newspaper and treating it like it was fact.

    WHY THE BILL FAILED wrote on Jun 21, 2007 12:07 AM:How could the Senate amnesty bill have possibly failed? It was supported by the president, the majority party and prominent members of the minority, plus Big Business, Big Labor, Big Media, and Big Religion. And yet the motion Thursday night to end debate and move to a final vote on the bill was soundly rejected, failing to garner even a majority, let alone the necessary 60 votes. THE REASON WAS SIMPLE - PUBLIC OUTRAGE!

    Bob wrote on Jun 21, 2007 12:27 PM:Bovine Excrement!

    Syl wrote on Jun 21, 2007 3:53 PM:I thought Illegal Aliens could not vote. I highly doubt the jest of this story for accuracy. I get around and I do not know anyone in favor of Amnesty.

    Syl wrote on Jun 21, 2007 3:54 PM:Just 14% of Americans have a great deal or quite a lot of confidence in Congress. This 14% Congressional confidence rating is the all-time low for this measure, which Gallup initiated in 1973. The previous low point for Congress was 18% at several points in the period of time 1991 to 1994. Congress is now nestled at the bottom of the list of Gallup's annual Confidence in Institutions rankings, along with HMOs. Just 15% of Americans have a great deal or quite a lot of confidence in HMOs. (By way of contrast, 69% of Americans have a great deal or quite a lot of confidence in the military, which tops the list. More on this at galluppol... on Thursday).

    Alfonso wrote on Jun 21, 2007 5:01 PM:Bob....that would be "Male Bovine Excrement"...Gee, what would happen if they let us American Voters decide the immigration issue so we could determine what America really wants instead of politicians, lobbyists and poll takers!

    To the NCT wrote on Jun 21, 2007 10:18 PM:Can you please do a real poll? Ask the question of your readers how they feel about illegal alien lawbreakers. How about? Do you favor Bush's amnesty bill? or do you want illegal aliens deported? or do you want illegals taking jobs away from American workers for much lower wages? or do you want American children have to go to school with a majority of a foreign language spoken, or do you want your children to have a mediocre education because of foreign speaking illegal children? Do you want our laws upheld regarding illegal aliens? Do you want illegals getting free medical care that you don't get? Do you want illegals getting free money for their children when your children don't receive any free money? Do you want overcrowded housing, crime, graffiti in your neighborhood?

    WE WON'T BE FOOLED AGAIN wrote on Jun 22, 2007 6:34 AM:We do not need the Senate immigration bill to secure the border. Congress has already passed laws authorizing border security, but the Homeland Security Department has failed to fully implement them. The administration already has the authority to build hundreds of miles of border fencing, hire and train 6,000 border patrol agents, end catch and release and create a national employment verification database. Essentially, all of the security benchmarks in the current Senate bill are already law. Unfortunately, proponents of this bill would have us believe that none of these security measures can be implemented unless we pass a bill that grants amnesty to 12 million to 20 million illegal immigrants. In short, security is being held hostage in return for amnesty.

    What the Senators are Hearing wrote on Jun 22, 2007 6:51 AM:Our constituents are very clear. Over ninety percent, probably over ninety-five percent of all our calls and emails and letters are telling me to keep fighting to kill this bill. And they see it as a much bigger issue than immigration. They see it as a selling out of America - some kind of betrayal.

    They Polled Who????? wrote on Jun 22, 2007 6:55 AM:A coalition of groups supporting immigrant rights (ILLEGAL ALIENS) released a poll .............

    Ali wrote on Jun 22, 2007 7:09 AM:I don't believe this BULLCRAP for one minute!!! This makes me angry b/c they are trying to spin the facts. There is not ONE person I have talked to in the last three months that would want to legalize 20 million criminals!! Totally don't believe this crap and I feel sorry for those who do. WAKE UP AMERICA!!

    HapTexan wrote on Jun 22, 2007 7:11 AM:I trust this info as much as i trust kennedy. I bet they asked one illegal the same question over and over again to get those numbers. This rag is so out of touch with the public it should only be used to line bird cages.

    Win wrote on Jun 22, 2007 7:12 AM:If this poll is valid, the rest of the voters in the U.S. are overjoyed that this county does not make the decisions for all of us. We are fed up with this and want the law enforced both on the border and in the interior by Federal, State, and local governments. There doesn't have to be a midnight roundup. Is all it takes is closing the borders and enforcing the law. If they want to be citizens of this country they can apply the legal way. Further, government needs to improve the technology and process for background checks to stream line the process.

    Born in the USA wrote on Jun 22, 2007 7:18 AM:A poll which was given to PRO-ILLEGALS say illegals want amenesty well DUH! How ignorant do you think legal Americans are????

    Alex wrote on Jun 22, 2007 7:50 AM:This is the stupidest article I've ever seen. "A biased group in favor of ILLEGAL immigration finds most people want it." RIDICULOUS!

    Alex wrote on Jun 22, 2007 7:53 AM:Problems: ENERGY crisis INCREASING CRIME LOWERING standard of living INCREASING taxes INCREASING infectious diseases gang problems ONE SOLUTION addresses all that and more!!! Close the border and deport.

    JokeOfAPoll wrote on Jun 22, 2007 8:28 AM:Ya right. This poll has a much credibility as Jorge Bush!! This is a bunch of BS and WE, THE AMERICAN PEOPLE KNOW IT! We will NEVER support amnesty!

    Alfonso wrote on Jun 22, 2007 9:26 AM:Secure the borders and stop the flow of illegals by using fences, technology and if necessary, harsher attitudes than we have been able to foster until now. They must learn that it is illegal, unsafe and will be dealt with differently. If we implement an identity program for laborers and employers that will detect fraud and ID theft in a viable manner, the illegals would not be able to work, the employers would not be able to hire them and self-deportation would be expeditiously effected. At the same time, begin a guest worker program with secured authorizations acquired only outside of US boundries in foreign countries (all of them, not just latino nations), from US Embassy's offices, that would begin to provide temporary workers to fulfill our needs. Most illegals would immediately begin to self-deport (instead of self-immigrate) to acquire these new documents in their homeland, to get work; not affecting the lines to legal immigration and eventual citizenship. Those with families established under fraudulent conditions in America would just have to leave their children/family with legal residents until they can make arrangements to return legally or they can take their families back to their country of origin, their illegal acts brought this on them, not ours. Revise the 14th amendment to preclude citizenship for children born of a parent not legally in America. This is a huge incentive for young women from many countries that we must remove. If we remove the incentives for foreigners to immigrate illegally, they will stop. If we install incentives to join a work program for earning a living and not citizenship, we will meet their needs and ours. The guest worker program must enable opportunity for foreigners from all countries, not just our southern latino nations. America will realize an economic impact in any transition plan that changes the status quo but if we can quickly create the id and guest worker programs, a minimal effect will take place. We will begin to realize an immediate increase in tax revenue, a vast decrease in abuse of social services and a magnificent improvement in our country's security all while watching the illegals deport themselves. Try it, you'll like it.

    Jean wrote on Jun 22, 2007 9:46 AM:I could get poll results like this too standing in the middle of a Cinco de Mayo Celebration, predominantly Hispanic neighborhood, in a lot of Catholic Churches... No brainer! Random sampling of the general population will not yield these results. They know it and we know it and polls like these make them look as dumb as they are.

    The Patriot wrote on Jun 22, 2007 9:48 AM:Talk about media bias. This poll is a joke and you know they rigged the poll to get the type of answer they wanted! The article should have never been written. It is completely incorrect. Lets ALL write the editor and give poll results from "legit" polls that show the overwhelmingly support AGAINST amnesty!

    And, wrote on Jun 22, 2007 10:24 AM:I trust this info as much as I trust Bush, McCain, Snow, McConnel, Frist, Cheney, Graham, Hastert, etc, etc, etc.

    LynnS wrote on Jun 22, 2007 10:30 AM:... LOL! How about giving us some REAL journalism, not some of your small-minded agenda-based garbage over and over again? Your article states "The survey of 600 likely voters in the county" would be 600 illegal aliens who picked up the telephone where they live IN THE SHADOWS in San Diego County. The general population is NOT pro-amnesty nor are American citizens about to hand over full rights and benefits to illegal aliens who have committed crimes to get to America and live among us -- IN THE SHADOWS. This ... biased poll is not a bonafide poll, nor is the polling firm without an agenda. How about writing about the latest Zogby poll taken last week? That poll shows that just 3% of Americans believe Congress is handling the immigration issue in favorable terms. The Zogby poll also shows that illegal aliens who live and work within the U.S. are seen as a burden by 46% of Americans. Guess that wouldn't sit too well with your illegal alien readership, now would it...?

    Racist is right, wrote on Jun 22, 2007 10:45 AM:There is a lot of racism going on here. The illegal aliens and the pro-illegal supporters are very prejudiced against American Citizens and their opinions.

    Syl wrote on Jun 22, 2007 10:46 AM:Senators Trent Lott (R - Miss.) and Mitch McConnel (R-KY) have become the point Senators for the Republicans supporting this bill over the last week. They are feeling your heat! How about turning the heat up higher? They are starting to crack and crumble!

    We the People wrote on Jun 22, 2007 2:20 PM:Thanks Sly! I just wrote more letters to our so-called representatives. The John and Ken Show website lists them all, and has convienent links to their e-mail addresses. I just turned up the heat, now everyone, it's your turn! Write, call, e-mail and FAX. Be heard!

    DiggIt wrote on Jun 22, 2007 5:07 PM:I just wanted to say it. 600 hundred people polled at $26,000. Thats 43 bucks a pop for a poll that means nothing.

    CM wrote on Jun 22, 2007 5:57 PM:I do not think everyone would be in such an uproar if the illegal aliens were just doing agricultural and service jobs, however they are also taking the jobs of carpenters, electrician, nurses, etc. They are less qualified and will do these jobs for less then standard wages, thus driving out native born American citizens. These displaced workers then displace worker in other segments where they are less qualified and work for less money. The cycle ends with Big Multi National Corporations making obscene profits and the American workers wage being driven down. The Republicans want cheap labor. The Democrats want cheap votes. And the American worker pays the price.

    DiggIt wrote on Jun 22, 2007 10:04 PM:suckers!

    sippy wrote on Jun 22, 2007 10:05 PM:I loved Congressman Bilbray's comments where he states this poll doesn't represent the true American majority. How can they claim the "majority" when they've only polled 600 people? What did they do, stop at a home depot with a translator and poll the 600 illegal day laborers or something? SHEESH!

    What a joke wrote on Jun 23, 2007 8:49 AM:With half the people who get polled are illegal aliens, of course they are going to want to stay. We're so invaded by Mexico right now. We need to stand up to them like we did in the Mexican American War and show we are a sovereign nation, independent from Mexico. It's time to gain our independence back.

    Fran wrote on Jun 23, 2007 12:03 PM:Also go to the Lou Dobbs website for more illegal alien info, as well as Ramos and Compean info, and address's and email info. I write, email or call every single day to let them know that I will not vote for any candidate who supports amnesty. That candidate also cannot be a far right person who will deny a womens right to choose. Or who does not believe in science.

    THIS IS FUNNY ! wrote on Jun 23, 2007 1:27 PM:Google "Fairbank, Maslin, Maullin & Associates". They are also based in Oakland, California, and Madison, Wisconsin. BUT WAIT ! THE BEST IS YET TO COME ...... The firm also has an affiliate in MEXICO CITY. I DID FIND IT STRANGE THAT MOST OF THE OFFICERS OF THE COMPANY HAVE HISPANIC SURNAMES !!! R/ Skip

    Syl wrote on Jun 23, 2007 2:11 PM:LOL The truth is out. First you take pro-Illegal aliens groups, and a Liberal Based Public Opinion Polling (PROPOGANDA) group with ties to Mexico, and then you get Edward to write a story, and then it gets published in the NCT, and then all the people who read this story will feel sympathetic towards the Illegal Aliens who are vying for free Amnesty. Gee now that was easy to figure out. I just worry about all of the older people who only have the newspaper as their source of information.

    Fedup Deb wrote on Jun 23, 2007 2:18 PM:RE: The firm also has an affiliate in MEXICO CITY >>>> This only confirms the extreme level of desperation existing in the pro-illegal camp. They are pathetic. We don't have to resort to fake polls. We have the truth on our side.

    John wrote on Jun 23, 2007 2:28 PM:Absolute BS.( and that's not Barbra Striesand ). If you people are going to hold poles, hold them with the legal residents in Escondido and North county. Quit lying to us.I have Latino neighbors who dont want them here, they drive down wages and increase rents. Not to mention makeing an hour long stay to the Emergency room a 6 hour visit. Which I get to pay for.90 percent of us are fed up.

    LJ. wrote on Jun 23, 2007 2:43 PM:Americans can not get a job in Mexico,but our tax dollars support many free programs for illegal aliens. Our health care systems are being drained because of our loose borders. Our schools and our welfare system is under heavy burden.

    FOR A DOSE OF REALITY, SEE THIS STORY wrote on Jun 24, 2007 7:48 AM:Escondido had 25 percent of county's illegal immigrant arrests in May http://www.nctimes.com/articles/2007/06/24/news/inland/62307181553.txt

    Alf wrote on Jun 24, 2007 10:21 AM:The first words in the article, "A coalition of groups supporting immigrant rights", shows how the title can happen. Would you expect otherwise? Would you expect Ford to publish an article that says that G.M. is better? They did not survey me or most people I know. Still an unabashed Libertarian, Alf.

    J.B. wrote on Jun 24, 2007 2:00 PM:The sample, according to the poll results, was 87 percent U.S. born and 72 percent white.

    Bill B wrote on Jun 24, 2007 4:27 PM:Send the all back to Mexico where they belong

    Green man wrote on Jun 24, 2007 9:07 PM:LEGALIZE POT FIRST!!! Stop arresting Americans!!!

    Alf wrote on Jun 25, 2007 6:07 AM:As with anything, "J.B.", even with "87 percent U.S. born and 72 percent white" it is quite possible to find a target au