Which brand of tennis is more exciting?
By: LOREN NELSON - Staff WriterMen's
Just to be clear, we're talking tennis here. The action on the court. You know, actual serves and backhands and volleys. | ∞
By: MICHAEL KLITZING - Staff Writer
Women's
I think Loren, my boss, is trying to get me fired. Why else would he have come up with a topic that has me sitting around the office Googling Ana Ivanovic? It's research, I swear!
Surely his searches are turning up nothing interesting at all. Which, I suppose, is my point.
I must concede that men's tennis features the most dominant athlete on the planet, Roger Federer ---- a player who only loses when playing on clay against Rafael Nadal. The methodical, emotionless Federer comes across as an unblinking automaton; a tennis terminator.
Federer is the San Antonio Spurs of individual sports, proving it's possible to simultaneously induce awe and a yawn.
The women's game provides parity, NFL style. It's a mixed bag of contenders in which the winner of any given tournament could be Maria Sharapova, Justine Henin, Martina Hingis, Amelie Mauresmo, any of about 73 Russians or even a Williams sister.
Ah yes, the Williams sisters. Even if they don't shine as brightly as they once did, the women's game actually has two bona fide American stars.
Sad as it may be, it's a reality that for a mass American audience to pay attention, it needs a rooting interest. If the average American saw Roger Federer on one side of the street and Kevin Federline on the other, there's no doubt who the camera phone would be trained on.
On the men's tour, Andy Roddick ---- known by most as that tennis dude Mandy Moore was dating ---- is the highest-ranked (No. 5) and most recognizable American out there. But Roddick hasn't won a grand slam event in four years, and these days, when he's not losing to Federer (1-13 lifetime), he's probably busy caddying the Swiss star's bags out to his Mercedes.
The ATP's second-best Yank, James Blake, probably spends most of his time explaining to people that he's not that infamous "Baretta" star.
While its true there are no Americans in the women's top 10, the Williams sisters are a threat to claim any tournament at any time when healthy, especially now that Venus is back on her game and fresh off a win at Wimbledon.
Venus and Serena are not only household names, they have combined for 14 Grand Slam titles. Plus, like many others on the women's tour, they have personality.
And don't use the tired line of style over substance. Models posing as tennis players like Anna Kournikova get chewed up and spit out by the WTA. While Sharapova, Serena Williams and Ivanovic may pose for a photo spread or two, they've also proven they have ample game.
Convinced? Good. Back to Google.
Contact staff writer Michael Klitzing at mrklitzing@gmail.com.
This isn't about the clothing lines, dangly earrings or who can wear the most scandalous outfit.
For Maria Sharapova, the Williams sisters and Anna Kournikova most famously of all, tennis is merely a means to an end.
Win a few tournaments, get a couple Grade B endorsements and that first, modest-sized mansion is all yours.
Win a Grand Slam, and you are endorsing so many products you can't keep track of them all. Pretty soon, the cameras are rolling and there you are, dressed as a bear and holding a dead salmon.
Heck, Kournikova never won at all. Not one WTA singles title. She is the Michelle Wie or Danica Patrick of tennis. Yet Kournikova is one of the most famous players ever, more recognizable than Martina Navratilova. All Navratilova did was win 18 Grand Slams.
Fame and fortune has a price. And for tennis divas, it is the quality of their play. It's hard to perfect that backhand when you're mixing fragrances at the perfume factory. It's difficult to run down every shot when you're wearing go-go boots.
Too many injuries, so many of them it's hard to guess anymore which ones are real and which ones are conveniences, have kept the outrageously talented Williams sisters out of too many tournaments.
Sharapova talks a good game, saying she is still young and has many more big wins in front of her.
Really? Judging by her Web site, Sharapova is more interested in fine dining (Koko's in Melbourne has great Japanese tepanyaki!) and spa treatments (Hot stone massages are the best!) than winning.
Sharapova, for all the hype, is merely the Andy Roddick of women's tennis. Like Roddick, she has a posse of A-list celebrity friends and no realistic hope of ever becoming one of the game's greats.
Men's tennis offers us a legend in his prime in Roger Federer. And there's a good chance Rafael Nadal might turn out to be even better.
Their championship matches at the French Open and Wimbledon were reminiscent of those classic Borg-McEnroe showdowns that left even the most casual fans breathless.
I can't tell you when the last great women's tennis match took place. But I did just see Sharapova in a Canon commercial.
That, sadly, wasn't very good either.
Contact sports editor Loren Nelson at (760) 740-3551 or lnelson@nctimes.com.
More Stories
Advertisement
- ESCONDIDO: Man shot dead at Fourth of July party (10804)
- TEMECULA: Protesters line intersection (6797)
- ESCONDIDO: Border Patrol employee in custody after hatchet attack (5667)
- ESCONDIDO: 3 DUI arrests, 46 impounds at checkpoint (5584)
- ESCONDIDO: City's dreams of an 'upscale' downtown may be dying (5110)
- HOUSING: Local median price up for third straight month (45)
- ESCONDIDO: Man shot dead at Fourth of July party (44)
- ESCONDIDO: Border Patrol employee in custody after hatchet attack (34)
- FALLBROOK: Peruvian chocolatier living sweet American dream (29)
- ESCONDIDO: Victim's roommate recalls July 4 shooting, friends gather for vigil (27)
Advertisement




