Vibrant Downtown Medical Village At Risk
By: WALLY GUTIERREZ and ROBROY R. FAWCETT - Commentary | ∞
Wally Gutierrez, left, and Robroy R. Fawcett are residents of Escondido.
The vibrant, downtown medical village promised to the residents of Escondido is withering away.
Once again, politicians and government bureaucrats lose their resolve after having convinced taxpayers to part with their hard-earned money. Best efforts are now being wasted on a cynical blame game as politicians and bureaucrats fail to deliver on their promises. Communications lack substantive information and overflow with vague promises. What is sorely needed is a joint workshop, with ample public input, to salvage the downtown medical village.
Palomar Pomerado Health, a government hospital district, promised to invest $73 million in renovating Palomar Medical Center in downtown Escondido if voters passed a $496 million bond to be repaid, with interest, by taxpayers. After the bond passed, the Escondido City Council opposed construction of a new hospital in a prime industrial park for fear of blighting the struggling downtown business district.
As a result PPH suggested a three-phase project to create the downtown medical village. The City Council agreed to the new hospital location on the condition that PPH commit to its promises, in writing, to create the village. The result was a memorandum of understanding between PPH and the city.
In Phase I of the downtown medical village, PPH committed to make an offer, by April 2007, on the properties needed to build a new 50,000-square-foot class-A, premier office building. This office building was to become the new corporate offices and headquarters for PPH, housing about six executives and 222 employees with a combined annual payroll of about $16 million. PPH has yet to make offers to purchase all of the needed properties, leaving Phase I at least eight months behind schedule.
In disturbing moves, PPH revealed plans to house only a portion of its administrative staff in an existing 10,000-square-foot downtown office building and to house the remainder in a building purchased near the distant new hospital location.
Also, PPH has emphasized that Phase I of the Downtown Medical Village has always been dependent on developer participation and financing. In short, PPH would provide the land, and a developer would provide the financing. To date, PPH has not secured a developer for Phase I, and the current downturn in the real estate and financial markets are creating a bleak outlook.
In support of Phase I, the city has allocated $2.5 million over the next two years for closing Valley Boulevard, giving the land to PPH, and reconfiguring Ivy to handle the crossover traffic now handled by Valley Boulevard. Until PPH secures a developer and financing for the new office building and headquarters, we doubt that the city will close Valley Boulevard and hand the land over to PPH.
In Phase II of the Downtown Medical Village, PPH promised to renovate the existing downtown hospital buildings. At the time, PPH was brandishing a $93 million renovation budget and visualizing a start date in 2011 and a completion date in 2014. Now PPH has cut the renovation budget to $3 million, and delayed those measly renovations until no sooner than 2015. Where did the $90 million go? PPH diverted the $90 million to cover expected cost overruns on the new hospital.
Palomar Pomerado is now committing to finance the remaining Phase II renovations with revenue bonds after it refinances or pays off existing revenue bonds, issued in 1999. One report places the financing event in 2017.
We are extremely skeptical of such promises. It appears that only about $60 million may become available. The unfunded portion of Pomerado Hospital, and the unfunded buildings at the new hospital, will have a higher funding priority when that money becomes available. The memorandum of understanding expires on Feb. 8, 2020. Also, politicians and bureaucrats have a hard enough time delivering on their own promises, let alone the promises of past characters.
Phase III of the Downtown Medical Village was originally scheduled to take place between 2014 and 2019. PPH was to acquire properties along Fig and East Valley Parkway, and the city was to close a block of Pennsylvania and give the land to PPH.
With developer participation, PPH was to construct housing, nursing facilities and offices. With the delays and difficulties with Phases I and II, we believe that Phase III is dead because the memorandum of understanding will expire long before Phase III can be brought to fruition.
Both PPH and the city are maneuvering to avoid blame. PPH talks of delays and promises financing in the distant future, after the present cast has left the scene, hoping the city refuses to close Valley Boulevard. The city acts ready to spend $2.5 million to close Valley Boulevard. However, only $500,000 of that money is actually committed. The remaining $2 million is merely an expectation. The city hopes PPH will admit that Phase I lacks funding, before it has to agree to close Valley Boulevard.
The CEO of PPH was expected to appear before the City Council on Oct. 24 to give a report on the Downtown Medical Village. That appearance has never materialized. However, the CEO has appeared before the respective boards of the East Valley Association and the Downtown Business Association, and is scheduled to soon appear before the Escondido Rotary Club. Unfortunately, PPH can ignore the City Council because the memorandum of understanding is full of loopholes. Most of PPH's commitments for the Downtown Medical Village are covered by the language "best efforts," "shall consider" and "good faith."
The city and PPH need to admit that the financial picture for the Downtown Medical Village has changed. Most importantly, the atmosphere of mistrust between the city and PPH must end. The PPH board does not trust the City Council, and the City Council does not trust PPH. Most communications have occurred through dueling letters, commentary and opinions published in the predominant local newspapers.
Instead, the City Council and PPH board need to have joint public workshops until the funding priorities can be understood and a realistic and cost-effective Downtown Medical Village has been secured.
Wally Gutierrez and Robroy R. Fawcett are residents of Escondido.
The vibrant, downtown medical village promised to the residents of Escondido is withering away.
Once again, politicians and government bureaucrats lose their resolve after having convinced taxpayers to part with their hard-earned money. Best efforts are now being wasted on a cynical blame game as politicians and bureaucrats fail to deliver on their promises. Communications lack substantive information and overflow with vague promises. What is sorely needed is a joint workshop, with ample public input, to salvage the downtown medical village.
Palomar Pomerado Health, a government hospital district, promised to invest $73 million dollars in renovating Palomar Medical Center in downtown Escondido if voters passed $496 million bond to be repaid, with interest, by taxpayers. After the bond passed, the Escondido City Council opposed construction of a new hospital in a prime industrial park for fear of blighting the struggling downtown business district.
As a result PPH suggested a three-phase project to create the downtown medical village. The city council agreed to the new hospital location on the condition that PPH commit to its promises, in writing, to create the village. The result was a memorandum of understanding between PPH and the city.
In Phase I of the downtown medical village, PPH committed to make an offer, by April 2007, on the properties needed to build a new 50,000 square foot class-A, premier office building. This office building was to become the new corporate offices and headquarters for PPH, housing about 6 executives and 222 employees with a combined annual payroll of about $16 million. PPH has yet to make offers to purchase all of the needed properties, leaving Phase I at least 8 months behind schedule.
In disturbing moves, PPH revealed plans to house only a portion of its administrative staff in an existing 10,000 square foot downtown office building, and to house the remainder in a building purchased near the distant new hospital location.
Also, PPH has emphasized that Phase I of the Downtown Medical Village has always been dependent on developer participation and financing. In short, PPH would provide the land, and a developer would provide the financing. To date, PPH has not secured a developer for Phase I, and the current downturn in the real estate and financial markets are creating a bleak outlook.
In support of Phase I, the City has allocated $2.5 million over the next two years for closing Valley Boulevard, giving the land to PPH, and reconfiguring Ivy to handle the crossover traffic now handled by Valley Boulevard. Until PPH secures a developer and financing for the new office building and headquarters, we doubt that the City will close Valley Boulevard and hand the land over to PPH.
In Phase II of the Downtown Medical Village, PPH promised to renovate the existing downtown hospital buildings. At the time, PPH was brandishing a $93 million renovation budget, and visualizing a start date in 2011 and a completion date in 2014. Now PPH has cut the renovation budget to $3 million, and delayed those measly renovations until no sooner than 2015. Where did the $90 million go? PPH diverted the $90 million to cover expected cost overruns on the new hospital.
Palomar Pomerado is now committing to finance the remaining Phase II renovations with revenue bonds after it refinances or pays off existing revenue bonds, issued in 1999. One report places the financing event in 2017.
We are extremely skeptical of such promises. It appears that only about $60 million may become available. The unfunded portion of Pomerado Hospital, and the unfunded buildings at the new hospital, will have a higher funding priority when that money becomes available. The memorandum of understanding expires on Feb. 8, 2020. Also, politicians and bureaucrats have a hard enough time delivering on their own promises, let alone the promises of past characters.
Phase III of the Downtown Medical Village was originally scheduled to take place between 2014 and 2019. PPH was to acquire properties along Fig and East Valley Parkway, and the city was to close a block of Pennsylvania and give the land to PPH.
With developer participation, PPH was to construct housing, nursing facilities, and offices. With the delays and difficulties with Phases I and II, we believe that Phase III is dead because the memorandum of understanding will expire long before Phase III can be brought to fruition.
Both PPH and the city are maneuvering to avoid blame. PPH talks of delays and promises financing in the distant future, after the present cast has left the scene, hoping the city refuses to close Valley Boulevard. The city acts ready to spend $2.5 million to close Valley Boulevard. However, only $500,000 of that money is actually committed. The remaining $2 million is merely an expectation. The city hopes PPH will admit that Phase I lacks funding, before it has to agree to close Valley Boulevard.
The CEO of PPH was expected to appear before the City Council on Oct. 24 to give a report on the Downtown Medical Village. That appearance has never materialized. However, the CEO has appeared before the respective boards of the East Valley Association and the Downtown Business Association, and is scheduled to soon appear before the Escondido Rotary Club. Unfortunately, PPH can ignore the City Council because the memorandum of understanding is full of loopholes. Most of PPH's commitments for the Downtown Medical Village are covered by the language, "best efforts," "shall consider" and "good faith."
The city and PPH need to admit that the financial picture for the Downtown Medical Village has changed. Most importantly, the atmosphere of mistrust between the city and PPH must end. The PPH board does not trust the City Council, and the City Council does not trust PPH. Most communications have occurred through dueling letters, commentary and opinions published in the predominant local newspapers.
Instead, the City Council and PPH board need to have joint public workshops until the funding priorities can be understood and a realistic and cost-effective Downtown Medical Village has been secured.
Wally Gutierrez and Robroy R. Fawcett are residents of Escondido.
More Stories
Advertisement
PPH and the City wrote on Jan 27, 2008 12:20 AM:Both PPH and the city are maneuvering to avoid blame. But we all now know the truth. "PLEASE" Less talk and more action.
Tax Dollars wrote on Jan 27, 2008 12:24 AM:WOW ! This is our Tax Dollars at work
What a mess wrote on Jan 27, 2008 12:33 AM:What a mess and us Taxpayers are paying for their mess up. Fire CEO Covert and the PPH Board
Escondido tax payers wrote on Jan 27, 2008 3:49 AM:were duped by the politicians and the PPH organization. Is there some way that we (taxpayers) can render Prop BB null and void since the "promise" to build hasn't happened. Can we "recall" Prop BB??? Anyone who knows please write on this blog. Thanks
Finally wrote on Jan 27, 2008 7:34 AM: Finally PPH and Covert are exposed. Good Job.
$ 90 Million wrote on Jan 27, 2008 7:52 AM: Where did the Downtown $90 million go? PPH diverted the Downtown $90 million to cover expected cost overruns on the new hospital. Downtown got screwed. This is what happens when you over promise.
Close Ivy Instead wrote on Jan 27, 2008 8:26 AM:The plan to close the Valley Blvd crossover is very ill advised. Instead, if the PPH offices are ever built, Ivy should be closed, with the PPH offices constructed on the west side of Valley Blvd. Ivy is the least used street in Escondido's downtown area and SANDAG is actively promoting walkable community projects. Also, East Valley businesses and residents are very concerned about the effects of closing Valley Blvd. Traffic may over load Grand, and flow through residential neighborhoods onto Oak Hill. Also forcing the traffic, now carried by the Valley Blvd crossover, onto Ivy will cause Ivy to become a high-traffic barrier to pedestrians trying to get from the new administrative offices to downtown business. A pedestrian bridge over Valley Blvd between the hospital and the administrative offices, would help draw hospital workers into the downtown area while allowing the administrative staff ready access to the hospital.
A sordid plan by PPH wrote on Jan 27, 2008 8:28 AM:It may take many years, but eventually I think these two will be proven to be right. PPH's goal was to build at ERTC at any cost. That included not fully informing the public of it's true intentions, abandoning things promised in downtown Escondido and at Pomerado Hospital and the like. It now appears that the PPH plan was to get quickly involved at ERTC to a point where they could argue that it was impossible to retreat due to financial reasons. The plan may still work, but it's a sad commentary on how much we can trust this organization.
Newsworthy! wrote on Jan 27, 2008 8:42 AM:Why is this information in the "Perspective" Section? If this information is accurate, don't you think it should be in the "News" Section? Shouldn't the North County Times be doing some reporting of their own on this subject? And I would hope that it wouldn't just be in the form of PPH press releases.
MOU wrote on Jan 27, 2008 9:01 AM:This MOU is a Joke and so is PPH
Wake Up wrote on Jan 27, 2008 9:02 AM: Wake Up Escondido! PPH is doing a number on you
Loopholes? wrote on Jan 27, 2008 9:16 AM:Covert did talk at Rotary, and softball questions indicated the audience either accepts PPH's changes, was too sleepy, or unwilling to disagree publicly. An MOU with a sunset clause makes this a one-sided deal: taxpayers pay, and PPH does whatever they want. We can't expect Covert to reverse now. Their Board apparently agrees. Council is "settling" for the RTC hospital because PPH threatened to pull the plug on Escondido if it didn't, and because they are walking a fine line, cultivating support for their eventual reelection bids. This all boils down to power (the ability to set priorities...with taxpayer money) and accountability. Just like "talks in the community" don't mean change, I am not sure "public forums" would either. Our at-large, elected representatives on the Escondido's City Council are the ones positioned to force/convince/persuade PPH to honor BOTH its commitments to the RTC and Downtown sites. A deal's a deal, and Council members should stay up late, camp out on Covert's doorstep or whatever it takes to do what is right for Escondido.
I agree with Newsworthy wrote on Jan 27, 2008 10:05 AM: Will the North County Times NOW start to dig in and find out what is really going on? ...
exposed! wrote on Jan 27, 2008 10:15 AM:This is not new information. This is simply the way PPH operates under Michael Covert's leadership. Is it any coincidence that many PPH employees who worked for Covert during the BB campaign are no longer working there? Wonder why. Could it be that these same questions and issues were raised following BB, and Covert needed to quickly clean house? Taxpayers know they were fooled. Employees were used and forced to work on the campaign whether we believed in it or not, then discarded soon after. People know the truth about PPH! The downtown village will never happen! It was just a way of getting the "naysayers" to shut up and go away! And if you get a chance, read the MOU - it is a bunch of fancy legal talk, but is in no way binding. The joke's on US!
Remember wrote on Jan 27, 2008 11:21 AM:... When will the NC Times start covering this mess ?
Promises Delayed and Unfunded wrote on Jan 27, 2008 11:59 AM:Three years ago, PPH said the new hospital would be 'built by 2009'.
www.nctimes.com/articles/2004/07/13/news/top_stories/7_11_147_12_04.txt Now PPH claims it will be finished in 2011. Increased costs have sucked all the funds from the downtown project into the ERTC hospital. The new hospital project schedule slips a day each day!
Duh! wrote on Jan 27, 2008 12:02 PM:Many of us predicted that downtown would be the poor stepsister of PPH because we knew PPH wouldn't have enough money for all this, and the downtown renovation plan was just a carrot to get the city and the taxpayers to vote for BB. Come to think of it, it wasn't even a carrot. It was more like a virtual carrot to sucker people into supporting this project while a ton of money could have been saved by using the buildings at the present site and building a new tower or two at that site. The city council should hold PPH to their promises!!
It's time wrote on Jan 27, 2008 1:16 PM: It's time for PPH to come clean and tell the Taxpayers what really is going on. It should not come from Covert or the PR department. It should come from the PPH Board.
VA Hospital Retrofit wrote on Jan 27, 2008 1:20 PM:Prop BB passed 38 months ago. In the meantime, the Federal government is finishing the retrofit of the VA Hospital in La Jolla for about $50 million. Building 1 is an 855,000-square-foot, 6-story cruciform structure that was built in 1970. The project was being completed in phases, supporting the uninterrupted operation of the facility. This facility provides a wide range of inpatient and outpatient services to nearly a quarter million veterans. The project was scheduled for a 30-month duration.
PPH poor leadership wrote on Jan 27, 2008 1:26 PM:Poor leadership and management has gotten PPH into this mess. It wasn't the result of the Escondido City Council actions. It wasn't the result those wishing to keep the downtown alive. It's unfortunate that PPH now is stuck trying to shift blame around to try to mask their own ineffectiveness. Do you think the CEO will hang around to see things crumble? Of course not. Just wait to see all of the finger pointing when things fall apart. CEO blames the PPH board. The board blames the CEO (and whoever else happens to walk down the street). It's a sad day for Escondido.
Very Smart wrote on Jan 27, 2008 1:38 PM: North County Times hire these guys they are VERY SMART our at least have them train your reporters
Beware wrote on Jan 27, 2008 1:41 PM: Beware another bond is coming! I bet PPH is going to call it son of Prop BB
Naysayer to 'exposed!' wrote on Jan 27, 2008 1:58 PM:We didn't go away and neither will PPH's deceptions. The authors of this piece are in good company. We saw this coming before the election and it only continues to get worse. And notice how more and more taxpayers are asking why the NCT isn't reporting on this. It raises even more questions!
Facts or Fantasy? wrote on Jan 27, 2008 2:32 PM:Three years ago, PPH Boardmember Nancy Bassett wrote the following: 'Fact 2: There is a known project cost. The total is $753 million; . . .Fact 3: There is reason why the hospital can't stay where it is. Independent seismic experts, whose work was necessitated by a state mandate, say Palomar can't withstand the minimum 6.0 earthquake, and it's actually cheaper to build a new facility, including the cost of land, than to retrofit and rebuild.'
www.nctimes.com/articles/2004/10/29/opinion/commentary/20_56_5410_28_04.txt Looking back, Nancy did not have a good grasp of the situation.
No More Bonds wrote on Jan 27, 2008 2:39 PM:The real estate market is in the tank. Homeowners cannot afford to fund any more massive bonds. www.nctimes.com/articles/2008/01/27/news/top_stories/1_01_991_26_08.txt
On time and on track wrote on Jan 27, 2008 3:22 PM:All the hospital plans and actions are on time or ahead of time and on track. Where do all these know-it-all losers get off trying to cast doubt and make accusations? What have any of them ever accomplished of ANY significance in their lives? I wager nothing.
No one is surprised that a patent lawyer and a bookeeper might have a different view on healthcare facilities planning and construction than a healthcare system board with over 200 years of frontline healthcare experience.....
Mr. Covert wrote on Jan 27, 2008 3:25 PM:Mr. Covert and Palomar Pomerado Health should be ashamed of them self’s. When will they start telling the truth????
Not trustworthy wrote on Jan 27, 2008 4:33 PM:PPH and everyone associated with them are not to be trusted. Weasel language and clever deceptions don't cut it. We don't believe a word they say. The sooner all facilities in the entire hospital district are leased out to private operators, the better it will be for all of us. PPH has lost our trust! Turn our healthcare facilities over to Scripps, Sharp or anyone with ethics ASAP.
Eric wrote on Jan 27, 2008 7:52 PM:Let's get Wally appointed as the CEO of PPH! With his integrity, the truth would be known!!
Mary G wrote on Jan 27, 2008 8:10 PM:I just received an e-mail about this story and I cannot believe it. PPH must start telling the truth.
Please wrote on Jan 27, 2008 8:13 PM:Scripps, Sharp or anyone with ethics please buy ... (Palomar Pomerado Health) our lives are depend on it.
Ralph wrote on Jan 27, 2008 9:07 PM:Fortunately the article is shown twice in a row as the first time I read it I couldn't believe my eyes!
If the bond measure asked voter for permission to borrow money for a hospital downtown, then how can they use the money for a different purpose?
Suckers R Us! wrote on Jan 27, 2008 9:36 PM:Mr. Mike is sooooooo smooth!
We give him $500 million because he promised the world and now we are learning it was just a bait and switch -- before the first brick has been laid even.
Being smug wrote on Jan 28, 2008 8:22 AM:And PPH does not respond. What can they say? They sit there smugly like a cat with a pet bird in his mouth. The time will come when they need the support of the citizens of Escondido. It will not be there, count on that!
To "On time and on track" wrote on Jan 28, 2008 8:40 AM:Unfortunately 200 years of frontline healthcare experience doesn't require character and integrity. On time and on track for what??? They will build a shell and then start begging for money. Their own figures show they are in trouble at ERTC. As far as downtown goes, you can forget about it! They have already raided the coffers and there is no money left for that. Their poor planning has put us all in such a deep hole we can't get out! All they can do is spin the bad news.
Who owns what?? wrote on Jan 28, 2008 8:45 AM: I wonder if Wally, Robroy or their sheep own any property around PPH that would make them wealthy people when the downtown redevelopment is completed. They appear to have self serving interests, instead of the good of the community as a whole. There's the story!
Estimate wrote on Jan 28, 2008 8:57 AM: Can you name one project that has come within the estimate or on schedule? I can't either. And now the Sprinter might open in March. I also don't hear anyone screaming about a 9 million dollar (plus) bridge so a few people can walk or ride their bike across Lake Hodges. If you're going to complain, don't wear blinders or be self serving when it only affects your back yard.
On Time & On Track? wrote on Jan 28, 2008 9:38 AM:Who on the PPH Board has experience in overseeing a hospital construction project? Marcelo Rivera - NO!, Bruce Krider - NO!, Nancy Bassett - NO!, Linda Greer - NO!, Alan Larson - NO!, Linda Baily, - Not hospital! Only Ted Kleiter who oversaw the construction of the Palomar Medical Center expansion in the 1980's as an administrator. This current Board is blind to what is happening. The hospital was promised by 2009. A schedule slip of at least 2 years over a 3.5 year period, combined with a 70% explosion in the budget, are ample evidence that the facilities expansion projects are not on time or on track!
Stuck with investments wrote on Jan 28, 2008 11:19 AM: If you read the 5th paragraph of this perspective, it tells the true story. "In Phase I of the downtown medical village, PPH committed to make an offer, by April 2007, on the properties needed to build a new 50,000-square-foot class-A, premier office building." The writters apparently didn't get an offer before the real estate market tanked. Now PPH will pay less for the land and save taxpayer money.
Sour grapes wrote on Jan 28, 2008 11:40 AM: Thanks PPH for saving our taxpayer money and not buying at the height of the real estate market. Maybe the greedy land speculators will lower the asking price for the land.
If I were PPH wrote on Jan 28, 2008 12:58 PM: If I were PPH, I'd wait another year before commiting to a land offer. Why buy high, there's no hurry. Work on the new hospital and let the market correct.
To sour grapes and If I wrote on Jan 28, 2008 2:03 PM:Don't you get it? There is no money to buy or do anything in downtown Escondido now or later. The money is being spent and will be spent on the white elephant ERTC Hospital. Buying downtown and involving a third party developer to build a quality class A building would require a long term leaseback by PPH at market rates. They will never do that. Instead, they have overpaid for a piece of junk three story building that may or may not have have some PPH office workers in it some day. That's it for you, downtown Escondido. Get used to it.
To If I were PPH wrote on Jan 28, 2008 2:19 PM:Does it matter if they had an agreement with the city? Or is this all about PPH ??????
PPH wrote on Jan 28, 2008 2:22 PM: Palomar Pomerado Health Admin is very BAD. The Doctors are Great!. Keep the Doctors and Fire the Admin Staff.
Little Hong wrote on Jan 28, 2008 2:25 PM: PPH's Mission Statement should be: Do as we say NOT as we do. (Trust Us)
Mr. Covert wrote on Jan 28, 2008 2:27 PM: We are very ashamed of you. The PPH needs to make sure that they keep their word to Escondido Taxpayers
Fool on the Hill wrote on Jan 28, 2008 2:33 PM:It is funny that 'Who owns what??' uses the word sheep. The main reason I got involved is that I felt like a sheep being herded around after I voted for BB and then realised just how badly we had been led astray. And NO, I don't own any land downtown and am not close to anyone who does. You might want to look in a mirror. Spin your 'story'...I prefer nonfiction when it comes to politics and healthcare.
PPH PR department wrote on Jan 28, 2008 3:06 PM: Hay who owns what ? Who gets free Charger Tickets. Who gets free LT Autographs. I bet the PPH PR department employees. Do they own land in Downtown ????
The Energizer Bunny... wrote on Jan 28, 2008 3:35 PM:This thing keeps going and going and going. I find it interesting that the only people who continue to bring this matter to the media's attention are the "naysayers". And rightfully so. Michael Covert and his team expect that if they keep ignoring the problem, it will go away. You never see Mr. Covert address the questions put before him. You never see him put out an editorial defending the hospital's financial issues. He and his team are so busy forming committees to decide which pro athlete to throw money at. The decision to pay LT $2 million from the PPH fundraising office - that's DONOR money - was the dumbest PR move ever. And now PPH wants to stick its head in the sand whenever anyone raises questions about the bond or the lack of money. It's funny - during the BB campaign, Michael Covert was EVERYWHERE - you couldn't escape him! And now he's nowhere to be found. Come on, PPH - step up and BE ACCOUNTABLE!!! Do what you said you were going to do!
lessons learned wrote on Jan 28, 2008 3:53 PM:Now we understand how the current PPH regime works and thinks. All of this was done in the most cynical, duplicitous and premeditated manner imaginable. There is no reason to give this group the benefit of the doubt going forward. Citizens of Escondido, spend your health dollars somewhere else. PPH is not to be trusted.
BE ACCOUNTABLE wrote on Jan 28, 2008 4:48 PM: This is very simple Palomar Pomerado Health needs to: BE ACCOUNTABLE AND KEEP THEIR PROMISES!
Charger Tickets wrote on Jan 28, 2008 4:51 PM: Free Charger Tickets and free LT Autographs. No new hospital ?? Now I know where our Prop BB money is at (Political Pork)
Tina wrote on Jan 28, 2008 5:04 PM: PPH is out of money $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
A New World Of Healing wrote on Jan 28, 2008 5:04 PM:Any of several private hospital chains could have done better than PPH hoped to do for less money, and without levying taxes on our properties.
Escondido Res wrote on Jan 28, 2008 5:07 PM: Will the City make PPH Accountable ?????
Peas wrote on Jan 28, 2008 5:38 PM:Covert and Escondido Mayor Pfeiler are 2 peas in a pod (Bad News)
Last Naysayer wrote on Jan 28, 2008 7:14 PM:Hey folks, haven't you noticed downtown Escondido is sewer, so why build a new hospital there anyway ? The escondido research park is clearly the ideal location to invest limited the limited funding that is available. I think there were many real estate spectators that invested in the downtown area surrounding the Hospital, and now you have sour grapes because of the delays. If you were reeally concerned about providing good healthcare to our community you would support the new hospital at teh research park...
My Town wrote on Jan 29, 2008 5:56 AM:This is my hometown will Lori, Ed, Sam, Marie, and Dick stand up for my hospital Downtown? This place has saved my life. and to Naysayer, Downtown is not a sewer. You must work for PPH remember when they said we had a dump in Escondido? Please PPH keep with the facts and stop pasting out bad info. Just do what you promised.....
LT wrote on Jan 29, 2008 6:12 AM:Mr Charger if you are hurt. Please do not use Palomar Pomerado Health go to Sharp, Scripps. We really need you for next season
Pity Them wrote on Jan 29, 2008 7:38 AM:Pity the poor souls on the PPH Board. They had no experience or expertise with large facility expansions, large expenditures or large projects, and made a number of horrible decisions. They wouldn't listen to those in the community who repeatedly and in detailed described how wrong and damaging their decisions were. Now they (and we) have to live with these decisions. The Escondido downtown and North County health care will suffer for decades because of their bad judgment and arrogance. They now just stonewall and hope the whole thing will go away. They can't face most members of the community who know them. The Escondido City Council had a rare chance to correct this obvious disaster but lacked the courage, the backbone, to do so. They had a once in a lifetime opportunity and failed. We are served poorly by these individuals.
Please Sell wrote on Jan 29, 2008 8:34 AM: PPH Please Sell to Childrens, Sharp or Scripps they have Great leadership and LT do not even charge them to say nice things about them
Going to Sharp wrote on Jan 29, 2008 9:13 AM:Sure glad they are fixing I-15. It is so reassuring to go down to Sharp and give my money and trust my health to a quality organization instead of supporting these clowns at PPH.
WallyG wrote on Jan 29, 2008 9:15 AM: I have a right to speculate and make money, as do all of you. My family has owned property downtown for years. Why should the rich only get richer? Don't forget to buy flowers for Valentines Day!
I agree wrote on Jan 29, 2008 10:23 AM: I agree with Please Sell "PPH Please Sell to Childrens, Sharp or Scripps they have Great leadership and LT do not even charge them to say nice things about them"
Downtown Medical Village wrote on Jan 29, 2008 10:31 AM: Downtown Medical Village ???? Oh! We are sorry we were just joking
Election year wrote on Jan 29, 2008 10:53 AM: Sam will jump on any bandwagon that may get him votes, so count on his support up til November. You may want to record the next East Valley meeting. And you can count on Bobby boy to run for an office.
Stick with the Facts wrote on Jan 29, 2008 11:10 AM: PPH "Please" Stick with the Facts. Is there anything incorrect with the "Vibrant Downtown Medical Village At Risk" Article? I know the PR department likes to spin things. Sorry PPH PR Department the "Facts" are the "Facts"
Cali Gal wrote on Jan 29, 2008 12:14 PM:I have an idea..let's turn the existing hospital into another Latino Market. Fits the demographics and economic demand of downtown Escondido to a tee! Hate to say it, but DOWNtown Esco is going DOWNhill a little more each day.
motivation? wrote on Jan 29, 2008 12:49 PM:it would be interesting to uncover the motivating force(s) behind the authors of this article.
State of California wrote on Jan 29, 2008 1:03 PM:yep, it's election year. what offices are gutierrez and fawcett (or their close buddies in escondido) running for? there you have the real "motivation"
White Coats wrote on Jan 29, 2008 1:04 PM:We are really in trouble if PPH sells off assets to cover cost overruns.
Motivation wrote on Jan 29, 2008 1:19 PM:Good government. The existing emergency room was built in 1988, and it the newest in the area. The hospital buildings are not 50 years old. The cost of retrofitting PMC was once set at $3-6 million. The district's population is not going to grow to anywhere near 1.3 million by 2024. The nearby Mission Park(formerly Grant Ave) area already has the fastest growing poverty rate in California. PPH promised a vibrant downtown medical village, not blight and a largely vacant facility.
Little Hong wrote on Jan 29, 2008 1:25 PM: Wally and Robroy are making my job harder. just trust "Covert" aka Mr. Mike's Traveling Miracle Medicine Show
Kaiser Initiative wrote on Jan 29, 2008 1:28 PM:My political goal this year is to get the agreement between Kaiser and PPH released to the public before the November elections. All of my 'buddies' roll their eyes when I mention it.
To State... wrote on Jan 29, 2008 1:32 PM:I thought I might run for the Historic Preservation Commission. You got me. YIPPEE! I'm going to be RICH, RICH RICH!
Come Out wrote on Jan 29, 2008 1:38 PM: PPH, Come Out, Come Out where ever you at and start talking to the public. “BEWARE” Tape whatever they are saying! Then you will find out how PPH keeps changing their story.... Remember PPH Facts not Fiction….
More motivation wrote on Jan 29, 2008 1:53 PM:I perceive that these writers really care about Escondido. If this kind of care would motivate our Chamber of Commerce (total PPH shills) DBA (heads in the sand), City Council (wishful and inept), or City Staff (lazy, overpaid and nonchalant) there is a good chance that PPH would not be able to get away with this punch to the gut of our City. Three cheers for the NC Times for printing this column and the guys who wrote it.
In the News wrote on Jan 29, 2008 3:18 PM: Little Andy Hong does a story of all the promises broken by PPH. Oh, then I woke up PPH doing the right thing "NOT"
Patricka wrote on Jan 29, 2008 3:29 PM:Robby and Wally = political partners or puppets? Either way, they "really care about Escondido." Yeah, RIGHT.
to "More motivation" wrote on Jan 29, 2008 3:43 PM:Shame on you for your comment which generalizes all City Staff as being "lazy, overpaid and nonchalant." I happen to know quite a few City Staff members who are quite the opposite! Thank you, City Staff, for your hard work and commitment to our City.
More motivation wrote on Jan 29, 2008 4:35 PM:Sorry that some may have taken my earlier comment as aimed at all city staff. However, the City Manager, City attorney and their staffs should have fully advised the council on the MOU. I doubt the Council was fully aware of all the loopholes and obligations that it contained. Are they presently advising the Council of any and all recourses available to them now. I doubt it.
Short String wrote on Jan 29, 2008 5:01 PM: Coverts on a Short String?
GustavoF wrote on Jan 29, 2008 5:02 PM: I need a raise It's hard to protect PPH and Covert
Gee wiz Wally wrote on Jan 29, 2008 5:04 PM: I like Mike and Little Andy!! You, Bobby and Dr. M would like them if not for your real estate. Don't cry it'll be worth more than you paid for it some day.
City and PPH wrote on Jan 29, 2008 5:04 PM: Go Public on the issue and eveything will go away
To Patricka wrote on Jan 29, 2008 5:21 PM: According to you only PPH really care about Escondido." Yeah, RIGHT ……….”EVERYONE” knows that is NOT true. …
GustavoF wrote on Jan 29, 2008 5:26 PM: I want a raise
To Gee wiz wrote on Jan 29, 2008 5:27 PM: You would
Go Public wrote on Jan 29, 2008 5:32 PM:PPH "Go Public" With Real Facts and come to a council meeting if you have nothing to hide
Little Andy wrote on Jan 29, 2008 5:34 PM: I hate my job This is not the "BEST" place to work at
Facts Not Fiction wrote on Jan 29, 2008 5:42 PM: PPH cannot handle the truth!.... KEEP your promises PPH!!!!!
More motivation wrote on Jan 29, 2008 5:47 PM:I don't know what all this silly, personal talk between parties is about. However, for "Gee Wiz Wally" to accuse those who are alarmed and horrified by PPH behavior as being mere real estate speculators is way off the mark. The premeditated and calculated breach of Prop BB and MOU promises by PPH will have longstanding detrimental consequences for the entire district. I doubt that PPH can or should survive this debacle in its present form. How much better it would be for all of us if the district leased out its facilities to professional hospital operators like Sharp, Scripps or even Kaiser! The trust and goodwill that this regime at PPH has squandered will not return unless there is a complete change of direction and leadership.
Dr.M wrote on Jan 29, 2008 6:01 PM: I'm sick of you low lifes. Just who do you think you're talking to. You are nothing. Wally and Bobby are mine, and you'll leave them alone!
Little Andy wrote on Jan 29, 2008 6:08 PM: I want a raise too. But they (PPH) say the do not have anymore money. Heck I'll stay here I like GustavoF, Covert, Wally, Robroy and even Larry
Hey, where's my post wrote on Jan 29, 2008 6:17 PM:Where is the post I entered this morning?
spectator wrote on Jan 29, 2008 6:39 PM:To: "City and PPH", who wrote on Jan 29, 2008 5:04 PM: "Go Public on the issue and eveything will go away" I'm just wondering....does that include Wally?
Having fun yet? wrote on Jan 29, 2008 7:15 PM:Well, the ten of you on this ridiculous blog are sure having a good time aren't you? I have a news flash for you --- It's over! The hospital is being built and guess what Escondido - we don't care! I don't live in the city and I can't wait to see the new facility. You really are all crazy if you can turn your head to the economics of having a state of the art health care facility in your community. The only thing the PPH Board did wrong was not vote to build the thing in San Marcos. Construction would have already started and then you'd be all alone, crying and hanging onto the old crusty building wishing you could recoop those lost property values. Talk about being left behind - Get over it already...
Truth wrote on Jan 29, 2008 7:54 PM:The truth is coming out. Darn that pre-election promise to build in Escondido. They tried to get out, but they keep getting sucked back in!
Three Hospital Solution wrote on Jan 29, 2008 8:04 PM:Having fun yet has one good point. Building a new hospital in San Marcos about the same size as Pomerado, and retrofitting the existing downtown hospital, would have been better for the district. The freeway between Escondido and San Marcos is clogged for much of the day. Now PPH will be stuck with a hospital overshadowed by the power plant's plume.
Another Spectator wrote on Jan 29, 2008 8:43 PM:including the CEO?
Show me the money wrote on Jan 30, 2008 4:01 AM:I don't see any tangible sign of 'the new facility.' I do see a huge plume from its next door neighbor. It looks like a tornado is headed this way. It will provide many intriguing photo ops for years to come. Covert's dream image, castle in the sky, with that ever-present plume as an accent. I'll provide the pictures - you provide the spin on the genious of siting this 'state of the art healthcare facility' right next door to a power plant.
To wrote on Jan 30, 2008 4:09 AM:Sorry pal but I saved the e-mail which stated that San Marcos never seriously considered PPH's proposal. It was a ruse and sham. It is very sad that so many fell for it. The truth shall set you free.
PPH PR Guys wrote on Jan 30, 2008 7:36 AM: Remember "The truth shall set you free"
Sam wrote on Jan 30, 2008 8:10 AM: PPH just keep your promises
Lori wrote on Jan 30, 2008 8:11 AM: PPH just keep your promises
San Marcos Bluff wrote on Jan 30, 2008 8:17 AM:Who needs secret emails. 'I think the hospital would be great,' said [San Marcos Mayor Corky] Smith, who added that he had recently spoken with Palomar Pomerado's chief executive officer, Michael Covert. 'I think they are serious about San Marcos, but I don't think Escondido is going to let them move.' www.nctimes.com/articles/2005/06/29/news/inland/0_00_286_28_05.txt The San Marcos site was going to require a small fortune in earthwork, and San Marcos was going to want some major infrastructure improvements. PPH got a great deal with the City of Escondido, yet they are now jilting Escondido. Shame on PPH!
Cruiser wrote on Jan 30, 2008 8:50 AM:First of all, there has been a great injustice done to the City of Escondido and its residents. PPH needs to be held accountable, there is no denying that. Now...as far as Gutierres and Fawcett being so passionate and caring about the livelihood of Escondidians...I don't buy it, not even for ONE MINUTE! One of the posters above stated "The Escondido downtown and North County health care will suffer for decades because of their (PPH) bad judgment and arrogance." No, North County health care will NOT suffer "for decades"...Escondido is going to have a BRANDS NEW, state-of-the-art hospital right across the freeway, less than 10 minutes from downtown Escondido! I wouldn't describe that as North County health care "suffering for decades." Gutierres & Fawcett obviously have their own PERSONAL agendas! Get over it-It's OVER! Now, let's focus our attention on our City Council and how they'll hold PPH accountable for their mistakes.
Chuck R. wrote on Jan 30, 2008 9:01 AM:"The truth shall set you free" what is this, an Oprah episode?? As someone above said "GET OVER IT!!" To the two writers of this article, please repeat after me: "GET OVER IT!" Let your city leaders do their jobs and handle this mess. I, like several other people on this blog, really have to question your motivations)for being so very moved about this subject, enough to write an article about it. What personal gain/loss are you incurring with/without the new hospital in downtown. You're going to have a new hospital, just a little further down the road. How does that hurt you??? Please tell us all!!!
tcmhOBESERVER wrote on Jan 30, 2008 9:03 AM:I sure hope the powers at TCMH in Oceanside will learn from this fiasco as they try and craft another bond issue for the tri-city home owners..it hasn't passed twice before, and three strikes, you're outta here.
LT wrote on Jan 30, 2008 9:11 AM:to "San Marcos Bluff" -- they're not "jilting Escondido." Esco will have its hospital, just in a different area of town than what was previously planned. So what, things change. That's the FACT. The truth shall set you free, don't you agree? So face the facts and MOVE ON already.
To Chuck R. wrote on Jan 30, 2008 10:16 AM: Chuck R., You do not understand the issues. #1. After Prop BB. PPH said they would build a new hospital. “Now” PPH does not have the money to complete the “New Hospital” They are cutting the children and women center and they don’t even have the money to build the central plant so they outsourced it. #2 PPH promised to upgrade the old hospital (MOU) they told everyone that they would spend $73 Million then $93 Million NOW $ 3 Million it is hard to build a “Medical Village” for $3 Million. So you asked what is our real motivation?. It is that public officials do not fulfilling their commitments and lying to the taxpayers. I am sorry if you do not believe it. But this is a fact. We are sorry you do not make your Public Officials accountable WE DO…..
Ed wrote on Jan 30, 2008 10:17 AM: PPH just keep your promises
Dick wrote on Jan 30, 2008 10:18 AM: PPH just keep your promises
Marie wrote on Jan 30, 2008 10:18 AM: PPH just keep your promises
marie wrote on Jan 30, 2008 10:19 AM: PPH needs to be held accountable
Ed wrote on Jan 30, 2008 10:20 AM: PPH needs to be held accountable
Lori wrote on Jan 30, 2008 10:21 AM: PPH needs to be held accountable
Sam wrote on Jan 30, 2008 10:21 AM: PPH needs to be held accountable
Jim wrote on Jan 30, 2008 10:23 AM:Everyone wants to move on and I am sure that is the PPH mantra. Too bad that the new site is such a disaster and the schedule is chronically delayed. The problem is that moving on means being OK with the train wreak called Prop BB. Why is it OK to build a hospital for the express purpose of pleasing Kaiser? Why not give the same deal to other private health providers? PPH needs to disclose the agreement like they are required by law to do. The contents must be so explosively controversial that they cannot find it in themselves to come clean. Some heads may roll. All the other promises for clinics, Pomerado, Downtown Escondido, etc wither away, but the Kaiser ERTC hospital must be built! Let's find out why. It is time to disclose the Kaiser agreement and all promises that surround it. Maybe then we can "move on" in a different direction.
Cruiser wrote on Jan 30, 2008 10:27 AM:to the person that insists on using the City Council's names while posting, shouldn't you be somewhere right now...like in a third grade classroom? give us a break & stop your immature behavior. ...
Jim wrote on Jan 30, 2008 10:36 AM:Everyone wants to move on and I am sure that is the PPH mantra. Too bad that the new site is such a disaster and the schedule is chronically delayed, meaning that they could still turn back. Delays like they are experiencing means that time sensitive contracts are now pretty much void anyway. The main problem with moving on is that means being OK with the train wreak called Prop BB. Why is it OK to build a hospital for the express purpose of pleasing Kaiser? Why not give the same deal to other private health providers? PPH needs to disclose the agreement as they are required by law to do. One can only assume that the contents are so explosively controversial that they cannot find it in themselves to come clean. Some heads may roll. All the other promises for clinics, Pomerado, Downtown Escondido, etc wither away, but the Kaiser ERTC hospital must be built, come hell or high water! Let's find out why. It is time to disclose the secret Kaiser agreement and all the promises that surround it. Maybe then we can "move on" in a different direction.
Tina P wrote on Jan 30, 2008 10:46 AM:I'd love to know who really wrote this article.
Citizen wrote on Jan 30, 2008 11:14 AM:Can I have my $$$$$$ back ???
to Tina P wrote on Jan 30, 2008 11:17 AM:Why question who really wrote it? Why question the motives? It is irrelevant. There is no reason to doubt that Wally and Robroy did the hard work necessary to ferret out the facts that PPH loves to obfuscate. Instead, reread what they wrote and concentrate on the facts. Realize also that PPH and their minions have refuted nothing in this article. Absolutely nothing. This is a terrible indictment of PPH, a public agency. Time for regime change.
ERTC Rocks! wrote on Jan 30, 2008 1:41 PM:Literally! Digging deeper (than 10 feet) will yield big surprises. What is the status of the joint venture between JRM and PPH for a Medical Office Building in the ERTC? Has it fallen on the rocks?
ERTC Soils wrote on Jan 30, 2008 1:47 PM:'I'm not trying to say that the hospital's on bad fill,' said Fawcett. 'But there's a lot of acreage up there that's not in accordance with the original design drawings and the (city's fill) ordinance.' Shanahan [PPH's Architect] acknowledged the soils report in question 'has some ugly numbers.' www.nctimes.com/articles/2007/12/02/news/top_stories/1_01_0312_1_07.txt
re: Soils wrote on Jan 30, 2008 1:55 PM:wow, you guys don't give up, do you? it's going to be built there, whether you like it or not. end of discussion!
The Principal wrote on Jan 30, 2008 2:07 PM: Gustavo, Little Andy, and Tina P you have been bad. (Passing out Fiction Not Facts) go to the Principal office. P.S. The Principal is not Covert
Plumage wrote on Jan 30, 2008 2:09 PM:I don't mean to ruffle any feathers since there is an agreement regarding the power plant's lack of liability to the hospital BUT it would be interesting to get a legal opinion on PPH's liability to the citizens/taxpayers/patients if its chosen location results in problems. Life Flight doesn't need to fly on cold damp nights, does it? Stay up late and check it out. The plume is huge!
To re: Soils wrote on Jan 30, 2008 2:09 PM: We have no problem with the ERTC… But keep your commitment to Downtown! Is your word wroth anything????
question for "Citizen" wrote on Jan 30, 2008 2:10 PM:please tell us how much money you should be getting back, if it were indeed possible to issue a refund to you? give us a specific dollar amount.
To re: Soils wrote on Jan 30, 2008 2:12 PM: Don't forget about the "ROCK" problem at the ERTC..... I am sure that that will not be the end of discussions about YOUR problems there.
re: plumage wrote on Jan 30, 2008 2:13 PM:what about the "plumage" above the ice skating rink? boy, i bet that's going to cause all kinds of major problems, too! i hope life flight doesn't need to maneuver around that plumage. sure is a disaster waiting to happen!
Little Hong wrote on Jan 30, 2008 2:13 PM: I'm glad they are not talking about me anymore.
To Little Hong wrote on Jan 30, 2008 2:15 PM: We know you are also passing out Fiction not Facts
To Tina P wrote on Jan 30, 2008 2:19 PM: We all know you do not think for your self. You do as "Mr. Mike's Traveling Miracle Medicine Show" tells you.
Tina P wrote on Jan 30, 2008 2:20 PM: Sometimes, I listen to Lori Holt also
ERTC Soils wrote on Jan 30, 2008 2:45 PM:PPH will go forward with an ERTC hospital, no matter the cost. That is the problem. The rocks alone has increased the grading costs to almost half the cost of the land. And that does not include costs for the rocks under the JRM/PPH MOB.
to the 2 Authors wrote on Jan 30, 2008 2:46 PM:We all know that you do not think for yourselves. You do as you are told to do.
If the truth will set you free - wrote on Jan 30, 2008 2:52 PM: And everyone wants the facts straight. We already know PPH's position, how about Wally, Rob, the Santrach's, that accountant (forgot his name), Sam and the others. Tell us what property you own or have a vested interest in (near PPH) and when it was acquired. Let us decide if your intentions are pure. You may garner more supporters for your cause. If NCT won't publish it, bring it to the East Valley meeting. We'll be there.
To 'to the 2 Authors' wrote on Jan 30, 2008 3:12 PM:The Authors are told what to do by who?
Property Check wrote on Jan 30, 2008 3:15 PM: I did a property and found out Tina P does not live in the Escondido limits. Covert, Gustavo, Tina P and Little Andy have higher value properties than Wally and Robroy. So your right the Rich get Richer and the poor get poorer
To: If the truth will set you free wrote on Jan 30, 2008 3:19 PM: Do a property check... The truth will set you free
Property Check wrote on Jan 30, 2008 3:24 PM: I did a Property Check and Wally and Robroy are not rich. Nice try PPH (The Rich Guys)
Property Check wrote on Jan 30, 2008 3:32 PM: Do Property Check's and the Facts will come out. Nice try PPH PR department.
PPH PR department wrote on Jan 30, 2008 3:34 PM: Maybe Wally and Robroy are being paid by Scripps, Sharp
What ne


