REGION: Bikes clog rush-hour Sprinter trains

District considers better markings for handicapped riders

By PAUL SISSON - Staff Writer | Monday, May 5, 2008 11:32 AM PDT

Bikes and commuters clog a westbound Sprinter train Thursday afternoon. Bikes have become an obstacle as crowds fill the new trains. Photo by Paul Sisson - Staff Photographer

NORTH COUNTY ---- In the end, it may be bikes that push the North County Transit District to add a second car to weekday Sprinter trains that are becoming increasingly crowded during afternoon commutes.

Take a ride between Oceanside and Escondido on any given afternoon between 3 p.m. and 5 p.m. and the back half of most Sprinter trains look like rolling bike shops.

On a west-bound train at 4:30 p.m. Thursday, bikes were stacked in a three-deep heap against a long row of fold-up seats. More bike riders stood in the aisles and doorways, holding handlebars as muttering passengers threaded their way through the mess.

"See all these people standing up?" asked regular Sprinter rider Chris Abenojar of Vista. "It's like this every day, they need to add another car like right now."

Transit district officials say they are aware of the problem, but are not yet ready to add a second Sprinter car during week-day service, which would double the number of seats available for passengers and also the amount of space to store bikes.

Abenojar, who stood with his own white mountain bike, said he sees the crush of two-wheeled cycles as proof that the North County Transit District should provide more space, at least in the afternoons.

But adding a second car means more cost for a transit agency that is looking at severe cutbacks to compensate for shortfalls in state subsidies that keep ticket prices affordable.

Karen King, the district's executive director, noted that the cost of diesel fuel --- which powers all Sprinter trains --- is continually on the rise.

Each Sprinter car contains two V-6 diesel engines, so doubling the number of cars also doubles the district's fuel costs. King said transit planners are working to find the point where a second car is necessary.

"We're tracking it very carefully so that we know when we have a critical mass that will require us to run two-car trains," King said.

Transit officials said they are not counting the number of Sprinter riders each day, but on April 4, the last day a count was conducted, 6,494 passengers rode the train. The transit district has said it would like to see the Sprinter carry 11,000 riders a day by this time next year.

Already, some passengers have said the bike jam on Sprinter trains has made things difficult for handicapped riders.

Since the Sprinter started running on March 9, the transit district has received some complaints from handicapped riders who use wheelchairs to get around, officials said. Some have complained that cyclists would not move their two-wheeled companions to make room for wheelchairs in the same fold-up seat sections where bikes park.

Sarah Benson, a spokeswoman for the district, said last week that plans are in the works to designate one side for bikes and the other for handicapped passengers.

"The plan is to make it very apparent that one side is for bikes and one side is for wheelchairs," Benson said.

Jason Hinkle of Escondido said he rolls his electric wheelchair onto the Sprinter almost every day during his commute to Cal State San Marcos. On Thursday, he tucked in behind a large black beach cruiser with little trouble.

Hinkle said he has not had too many problems fitting in with bike riders, who will generally move, if there is room to move, when they see him coming.

"I just ride right toward them, and right now I have no problem," he said.

But he added that he is worried about what will happen this fall when Cal State increases the cost of its parking pass to more than $300 per semester.

"Then we will have a lot more (students) riding," Hinkle said "If (transit officials) add another car, then that should help."

Contact staff writer Paul Sisson at (760) 901-4087 or psisson@nctimes.com.

Previous
Bookmark and Share

Advertisement

Pre-Registration Comments[-]Go to Top

Some of have to use wrote on May 5, 2008 6:25 AM:crutches, not as easy as an electric wheel chair.

Rider wrote on May 5, 2008 7:48 AM:Looks like the Sprinter is a success, no matter what the "I don't like change or anything new" people say. Add the car and let's roll.

Put bike hooks wrote on May 5, 2008 12:00 PM:on the outside of the sprinter.

Zephon wrote on May 5, 2008 12:07 PM:Any other business except for this public one would be relishing in such a similar increased demand for their business.

And they would work hard to ensure the quality and level of service levels to sustain the increased demand.

But NCTD appears to not really care. It was nice to see the recent UT article that also stated that NCTD has some of the highest costs of any transit district of similar size. I believe it was 27% of revenue is spent on administrative services.

Perhaps it is time to see some new administrators of this public agency that wants to reduce service levels and increase fares during a booming demand period. Apparently there is no accountability for their performance.

Where do people with wrote on May 5, 2008 2:25 PM:seeing eye dogs sit with all these bikes?

Critical thinkers wrote on May 5, 2008 3:34 PM:The critics were certain this "train to nowhere" would be empty, but now they're critical of how crowded the trains have become!!
Goes to show that ya'just can't please some of the people anytime.

Rita wrote on May 6, 2008 5:24 PM:Rumor? One security guard told me they were only supposed to allow 5 bikes. A 6th bike would have to wait for the next train. (I guess I'd have to start using I-78 again if I had to wait.) I counted 12 bikes Thursday at 5:45 pm heading to Oceanside, but there were no guards that day. There are only 2 bungee hooks on one side, but if everyone lines the bikes up straight and bungees them together, it works pretty good. Watch out for those electric wheelchairs. One lady got it in reverse against my hub and ruined my gears.

CruiserBob wrote on May 10, 2008 7:13 PM:Back in 2006 we were suggested that congestion of bicycles would be a problem and that a series of bicycle concessions at major stations could solve the problem before it became critical. See: http://www.northcountytimes.com/articles/2006/08/14/news/top_stories/81306190732.txt

We started a dialog with the "bicycle coordinator" for SANDAG who immediately poo-poohed the idea. It's as simple as this . . . "Bike rentals are to trains as car rentals are to planes".

We might also add that the highly touted parallel bike path does not go through the valley between I-5 and Coast Hwy where it is needed most. Average cyclists cannot climb Oceanside Blvd. with their groceries from Ralphs or Boney's. Come on NCTD and SANDAG. Let's finish the great work that you have begun!

Paul wrote on May 14, 2008 10:58 AM:The problem of each bicycle displacing several fare-paying riders and the unavailability of funding for the transit agency to simply double their operations costs to accommodate all the bicycles at rush hour can be largely solved by charging an additional full fare to bring a bicycle on board during the busiest times. Most recreational bikers would switch to riding the train at off-peak times. Others would pay their additional fare share to ride with their bike during rush hour. This would benefit the cash-strapped North County Transit District, ultimately helping to make more frequent train service more feasible. There are numerous transit systems around the world that charge extra for personal freight (such as bicycles) when trains and buses are crowded or only allow foldable bikes.

Paul

Registered Comments[-]Go to Top

Advertisement

Videos

Advertisement