About Our Ads | Privacy

'Wicked' judgment puzzles the Perfectionists

Font Size:
Default font size
Larger font size

The season finale of CBS' "Wickedly Perfect" was combined into a two-hour episode last Saturday. I had known the outcome of the contest since we wrapped filming in November 2004. However, I was fascinated to see how the show was produced and edited.

Perhaps the most amazing part is that Kimberly won the title of "Wickedly Perfect." After a record three trips to the Rock Garden for elimination, actually being eliminated and then winning a spot back into the competition, she won. Sounds like scripted TV at its best.

However, this unscripted reality show was so full of twists and changes, anything could and did happen.

The remaining five Perfectionists were assigned their final challenge by host Joan Lunden on Day 25 of the series. No longer did teams exist. Contestants would be judged individually. They were to travel to New York City for a screen test with CBS "Early Show" personality Hannah Storm. There, contestants received a makeover. Heather was not pleased with the choice of makeup, so she did her own, in a desire to control her "look."

Contestants were to demonstrate a craft of their choice and would be judged on screen presence, ingenuity, communication ability, and overall look.

Dawn assembled a table setting, but the judges found her voice to be too annoying for television.

Mitch demonstrated finishing touches to a floral arrangement, but the judges said he lacked enthusiasm.

Amy constructed an adorable child's toy from a necktie. Judge Candace Bushnell didn't like seeing a craft for children.

Kimberly began to show how to construct ribbon flowers. Host Hannah Storm was seemingly overcome with joy. The judges gave Kimberly high praise, even though she didn't finish her demonstration.

Heather created a purse from a skirt but was harshly criticized for her personal "look."

Kimberly and Mitch were chosen to be the finalists. They were challenged to throw a "coming out" party to introduce themselves and their magazine to New York society in a loft space with a party planner and a budget of $20,000. Mitch created his party's decor, magazine cover, menu and signature drink, while Kimberly relied on the expertise of her party planner and caterer to complete her party's look.

The verdict was in. While in the Rock Garden with all 12 Perfectionists, chef Bobby Flay found that his tie-breaking vote would decide who won. He voted for Kimberly, because he believed she was more "marketable."

The eliminated Perfectionists were puzzled by the judgment. We all truly believed that this competition was about genuine talent, which Mitch demonstrated in every challenge.

It is my sincere hope that Kimberly, as the winner of "Wickedly Perfect," takes this wonderful opportunity and soars to great heights and success. It is a dream prize that was coveted by 12 creative and talented people. To see the winner live the dream for us all will be reward enough.

Discuss Print Email

/